Cooja250 Rate My Team

[Cooja250]

Hi Guys,

All kinds of feedback wanted

Defenders
Shaw - Hartlett - Houli - Vlastuin - Stevenson - Russell (Pittard - Goodes)

Midfielders
Swan - Pendlebury - Deledio - Dangerfield - Zorko -  Wines - Mitchell K - O'Meara (Crouch - Viney)

Rucks
Hale- Leuenberger (Daw - Currie)

Forwards
Cox - Bartel - Pavlich - Rockliff - Robinson - Macaffer  (Rowe - Lee)

Cheers

[stew42]

Def: This is an awful line. I'm sorry, but it needs Gibbs and Goddard. Having Shaw and Hartlett in there will give you heart failure, Houli is consistent, but consistently mediocre. Is that Russell from Collingwood I spy? Could be a good pick, but wait for rnd 1. Your rookie picks are all sound. 5/10

Mids: I'm personally against having DPP in the mids, as it is more likely that a pure mid will score more than a pure fwd. Swan, Pendles, Lids, and to a slightly lesser extent Dangerfield are all good picks. Unique too. Rooks are also good. 8/10

Rucks: I don't like Hale. Sorry. Go someone like Bellchambers, Kreuzer or Goldy if you have the huevos. The others are good, I hope for your sake that NM decide to play with the two big men (phrasing) 6.5/10

Fwds: Cox is a good pick, I guess that's why you have Hale in there... I'd prefer to put Rowe into the rucks instead and use Cox/Rowe for Dpp if needed. Pav is a risky choice, getting older by the day (aren't we all?), and just had a baby, so sleep patterns will be out the window (I make a little joke!!!) Bartel is good, and unique around this forum, but not I fear in DT itself. Still a good pick. As is Rocky and Robbo. A good line, maybe too packed 9/10

Overall: 7.125/10  Good luck!!!

[Barra17]

So I did a little playing and came up with this, it is still your team essentially but with a few changes.

Bryce Gibbs, Heath Shaw, Hamish Hartlett, Nick Vlastuin, Jasper Pittard, Brett Goodes
Lewis Stevenson, Dean Terlich

Dane Swan, Scott Pendlebury, Brett Deledio, Jack Redden, Patrick Dangerfield, Oliver Wines, Kane Mitchell, Brad Crouch
Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney

Dean Cox, Matthew Leuenberger
Majak Daw, Sam Naismith

Jimmy Bartel, Matthew Pavlich, Dayne Zorko, Tom Rockliff, Mitch Robinson, Brent Macaffer
Tom Lee, Sam Rowe