Heppell or Hartlett?

[Adamant]

While I rate Hartlett as a good pick, Fyfey will absolutely smash him in averages. I reckon Hartlett - 90 / Fyfe - 100-105.

But keep Birch in there, he is a great unique with his amazing consistency. I've got him at D4 too.

[Grazz]

I've made the move to get Fyfe

My Backline is now:
Goddard, Stanley, Gibbs, Birchall, Pittard, Goodes, Docherty, Terlich

My Midfield is now:
Swan, Pendlebury, Redden, Murphy, Fyfe, Mitchell, O'Meara, Crouch, Neade, Viney

I'm really looking forward to Fyfe. I've only heard positive things about him and was chosen as a rookie in my 2011 dreamteam over Ballentyne which really worked out then but after 2012 thought he'd turn out like Liam Anthony

I could go Birchall to Heppell but I don't really feel comfortable about it. Everyone has told me Heppell will average more, but Birchall still seems like the safe choice to me. If I could find the cash to do a Birchall -> Grimes trade I'd make it which means I'd only have to free up $20k

Looks good mate, go with your gut regarding Birch/Hepp its easier to live with than being talked out of something that comes off and if it doesnt you backed yourself and thats easier to swallow.

haha cheers man. That is good advice I'll stay with Birchall, I think I'll keep Grimes as an upgrade target this season so I have something I really want to work for in my backline

Good idea to have a plan mate adds extra incentive when you have a target to chase. Goodluck for 2013.