Which ruck has most scope for improvement this year?

Started by Dutchie64, March 01, 2013, 09:37:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jukes

My top 5 rucks
Cox- 98
Maric- 97
Ryder- 94
Bellchambers- 92
Roughead- 92

imo you have to have one of them unless you're being a super cheap-arse.

Sandi will avg about 95...when he plays...

Holz

Quote from: Master Q on March 02, 2013, 12:06:51 PM
Quote from: Toga on March 02, 2013, 09:11:08 AM
Why no love for Maric Holz?
I reckon people think he won't score as well as he did last yer.

Don't have him in DT atm but have him in my UF league  8)

I dont pay full price for players who only have had one premo year. So no zorko,danger,beams,maric,cotchin in my starting sqaud. I didnt start goldy for that reason last year.

I dont see maric lfiting his average and i would rather go for a proven player if im just intending their average to stay around the same. So cox over maric anyday.

Just feel with goldy at 400k and mummy at 420k they pose less risk as i cant see them dropping (unless injured). Goldy for me backed up his scoring of 2011 to an extent, for games where he was hmacless and fit he went around 95.

Maric could do a cloke who knows, however i do pick up guys who have had an off year, so goldy and cloke im looking at,.

Master Q

Quote from: Jukes on March 02, 2013, 12:11:23 PM
My top 5 rucks
Cox- 98
Maric- 97
Ryder- 94
Bellchambers- 92
Roughead- 92

imo you have to have one of them unless you're being a super cheap-arse.

Sandi will avg about 95...when he plays...
Yeah I have Cox, not really a fan of Belly and Ryder and unsure about Maric and Roughy  :-\ At this stage I have Goldy and Burger, with Cox up front linking with Rowe.

elephants

I think you're talking shower with Belly/Ryder but I hope not...

#draftteamruckcombo

Where's Sauce and Big Boy McEvoy in that top 5?

Master Q

Quote from: elephants on March 02, 2013, 02:36:38 PM
I think you're talking shower with Belly/Ryder but I hope not...

#draftteamruckcombo

Where's Sauce and Big Boy McEvoy in that top 5?
Nope - not a fan of either  :)

pommyadam

i'm really looking for 85+ as an R1 (90 would be ideal, but considering only 5 rucks topped that last year, i'm not holding my breath)

of the 5
Cox is in the forwards
Roughy i'm not convinced on
Ryder's too inconsistent
Sandi's injured
and MAric is too darn exxy

i currently have Minson

Adamant

Quote from: pommyadam on March 02, 2013, 04:15:35 PM
i'm really looking for 85+ as an R1 (90 would be ideal, but considering only 5 rucks topped that last year, i'm not holding my breath)

of the 5
Cox is in the forwards
Roughy i'm not convinced on
Ryder's too inconsistent
Sandi's injured
and MAric is too darn exxy

i currently have Minson

McEvoy?