HELP! Moloney or Ball

[nperera95]

Please vote. Need your opinion :)

[GM]

Moloney is primed to get back to his 2011 form.Great value for SC scoring.

[Southstorm]

Moloney will definitely go better this season so if you can find an extra $60k, he'd be the one if you're looking for a steady scorer. If you just want a player to earn money, Ball is no worse of an option.

[thewizz]

I've gone GAJ, Swan, Pendles, JPK then Moloney. Think he will score well, may become a keeper or an easy sideways to a fallen prem.

[quinny88]

Moloney a good option but he does cost a fair chunk more than ball

[Mat0369]

Moloney

[Colliwobblers]

Ball. He is a mighty Magpie.

or a better reason?

2008 -2011 scores - lets ignore moloneys drop in form/favour and Balls injured 2012.

Moloney - 72 - 94 - 83 - 99

Ball - 99 -86 - 89 - 98

Flip a coin?  Both will be the #1 in and under clearance midfielders at thier club.

Ball 28, Moloney 29 , Moloney coming off a shocker, Ball coming off an injury....

Ball is cheaper.

Not a chance on Earth either will become a keeper IMO never have been never will be.

[batt]

Moloney a good option but he does cost a fair chunk more than ball

This is what confuses me about the poll results.  I see the chances of either featuring in the final midfield being very slim.  Therefore the reasonable choice would be the one that becomes the fatter cow?

[Mat0369]

Ball has to play at least one NAB cup game to be considered. Lenny Hayes and Adrian Peterson are the only two players I have seen have that large an impact in such a short time after a knee injury.

[Colliwobblers]

Ball has to play at least one NAB cup game to be considered. Lenny Hayes and Adrian Peterson are the only two players I have seen have that large an impact in such a short time after a knee injury.

good point Mat but is anyone really any harder than Ball? I'm backing him in but will also want to see something from him in Nab Cup.

still $60K is only wines over another mid rook - it's not a lot of coin so i would advise going with your gut. more will go with moloney.

some will go with embley but i don't think i would risk it, however at the price the reward is greater than both of these....

[quinny88]

Ball has to play at least one NAB cup game to be considered. Lenny Hayes and Adrian Peterson are the only two players I have seen have that large an impact in such a short time after a knee injury.

good point Mat but is anyone really any harder than Ball? I'm backing him in but will also want to see something from him in Nab Cup.

still $60K is only wines over another mid rook - it's not a lot of coin so i would advise going with your gut. more will go with moloney.

some will go with embley but i don't think i would risk it, however at the price the reward is greater than both of these....

Ball is as hard as they come but a returning from a major knee injury is nothing to do with hardness.
He would have to play a nab game it 2 for me to pick him. He should play next week or the week after