made some changes give us a look

[LMA12]

free image hosting

made some changes to backs and fwds.
thoughts on stevie j?
rookies will all be subject to nab cup performance.
really think goldy should go back to his best with pretty much 100% ruck again.
atley could be changed for yarran if he decides to turn it on.
koby stevens can also be swapped for another rookie, perhaps wines, guess its just a matter of nab cup.
just cant afford ablett, but i also dont think he can keep his 750k price tag for the whole season, one game of 100 should see his price drop a bit and ill jump on him for sure


anyway, rate and see what you all think and i'll try my best to rate yours back:)

[RedCats]

Backs - Keep Atley or Yarran, but I certainly wouldn't keep both. Look at trying to get another rookie in there. Use some of that money to upgrade Hanley or Harbrow to Gibbs, Shaw, Birchall  etc..

Mids are solid

Rucks, yeah yeah, seen that a few times (including my own!)

Forwards - Lose Kennedy, but don't replace with another mid-pricer, look at another rookie. I would think that an extra couple of rookies across the board will give you options a bit later in the season to upgrade. Probably look at upgrading your forward line a touch.

Pretty solid start though

[ando_10]

backs: yeah agree with redcats. keep atley or yarran to much of a role of the dice with both. and harbrow eh. dont like him as a fantasy player really.

mids: looking good one of the first teams ive seen with longergan in it.

rucks: yep standard and good

forwards: lose kennedy maybe try stringer. he is ready to go IMO and after last year im right off dusty apart from that its sound

7/10

heres mine if ya dont mind having a look

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72011.0.html

[tor01doc]

Down back I'd be happy with both Atley and Yarran - not likely to lose much and stand a lot to gain if they both fire. Only have to average an average of 80 to make a bit and be worth holding for a while until you see who's doing what.

I don't think it's too much of a roll if the dice to have both - at least you know they'll play and that is handy early on in the season. You can jump on bubble boys later if you have erred.

Harbrow - not for me.

I think you need to start 2 of the top 3 - (Ablett / Swan / Pendles) as what chances any not being there (ie top 8) at the end of the year. Might as well start and reap the benefit of points and save trades later.

Five mid guns means higher chance of getting one wrong and also missing out on the golden goose, the cash cow, the mid rookie goldmine that we see most years. Also takes from other lines and leaves you needing to field fwd and back rookies who are crapola.

So your rucks - nothing to add except - Prius? Great Wall? Kia?

Fwds - Your F 1 and 2 were F 6 and F 12 overall last year. Not that scary in a league match up.

Martin and Kennedy could both end up in the bin so prefer others.

Did you mention Didak?   :o

Good luck.

[Hiso]

Backs - i would swap harbrow to gibbs, and drop either atley or yarran because theres lots of decent rooks in def this year so no need to go to D5 with mid priced players.

Mids - like them

Rucks - standard

Forwards - with earlier cash saved u can make kennedy into broughton.

I don't like the forward rooks as much as the back rooks so i would go F5 with broughton so only have to have one good forwward rook.

don't know how much u would have left over depending on ur back rook  choice but may be able to swap roughy for cox

[Whippet]

I like the team but just not sure on Harbrow as previously posted.  Doesn't strike me as a week in/week out kind of player...was he consistant last year?

[barnsey70]

backline too many mid priced players, mids need gazza what are u thinking ?
upgrade rucks and fwd line is good!!
6/10 overall

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: You have spent too much money on your defence i would get rid of Harbrow for starters you need a premium such as Birchall in that spot
Mids: No Gazza may Hurt your team otherwise your midfield is great.
Rucks: Standard
Fwds: Lose Kennedy for Neade or Mayes

My Suggestions are to Upgrade Harbrow to Birchall or Shaw
Downgrade Kennedy to either Neade or mayes
Maybe lose Atley for a rookie.

[LMA12]

had another crack, taken the advice on board.
what do you guys think?