Embley or Wines ????

[Mark]

Who do you think we score more and be a beeter pick ?

Is it worth paying $114,000 more for an experecned Embley over a Rookie Wines ??

[Hagebear]

Half/half I reckon. Embley seems to be as fit as he's been in a long time, doing PB's this Preseason, And Ollie seems likely to be the highest scoring SC rookie with a really good JS. I think Embley will score more but will it b worth the extra $$$.... Not sure. But I'm giving the points to Embley on the basis he's seems as fit as he's been in a long time and averaged 96 from 21 games in 2011

[tbagrocks]

Embley has to score more surely? Just have a look at Wines in pre-season first before putting him over Embers

[Nige]

Could go either way. Watch the NAB Cup before making a call, I think.

[LF]

Why not have both if you can?

[Nige]

Also a good idea ^

[thefuzz]

Wines all the way

[Mark]

yeah think ill prob keep an eye on NAB cup. Thanks heaps guys and Gals

just hard to pick what mid rookies to go..

Current midfield...

Ablett, Pendels, Swan, Cotchin, Ball, Embley, Crouch, Viney (O'Meara , K.Mitchell)

who should i trade for Wines...

was thinking either Ball or Crouch ??

[Nige]

yeah think ill prob keep an eye on NAB cup. Thanks heaps guys and Gals

just hard to pick what mid rookies to go..

Current midfield...

Ablett, Pendels, Swan, Cotchin, Ball, Embley, Crouch, Viney (O'Meara , K.Mitchell)

who should i trade for Wines...

was thinking either Ball or Crouch ??

If that's the case, I'd say Ball.

[LF]

Go with Ball simply because he is no certainty to play round 1 yet.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71595.0.html

[Hagebear]

Yeh definately Ball out for Wines. He's very underdone and I don't think he'll score as much as previous years.

[Mark]

yeah so do you think Wines will score more than Ball each week then ??

[tbagrocks]

yeah so do you think Wines will score more than Ball each week then ??

No when Ball finds fitness, but still possible, just don't bank on it, I doubt Wines will play the whole 22 games, hopefully he's an upgrade at the byes, but if you keep could be great so ???