rate this and ill rate ya back :)

[ando_10]

back: goddard, gibbs, birchall, pearce, staker, docherty
emg: terlich, van unen

mids: GAJ, swan, cotchin, jack, ball, wines, o meara, viney
emg: goodes, crouch

rucks: cox, luenberger
emg: witts, currie

forwards: buddy, roughy, walker, rockliff, stringer, macaffer
emg: daniher, membrey

12k left

[LF]

Nice backline I`m seeing Pearce in a few teams now could go bang at the Dockers this season.
Good rucks just keep an eye on Coxy with his finger injury.
I don`t know about Buddy and Roughy the Hawks have a tough start to the year.
Walker could go bang with Tippet gone.
Mids look good I have Jack he has a great average against the teams the Swans play for the first few games.

Have you thought of running 5 premo mids plus Ball or Embley someone like Murphy,Fyfe or Mundy for example.

My team thread if you want to have a look the last pic is my current team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71466.0.html

[ando_10]

Nice backline I`m seeing Pearce in a few teams now could go bang at the Dockers this season.
Good rucks just keep an eye on Coxy with his finger injury.
I don`t know about Buddy and Roughy the Hawks have a tough start to the year.
Walker could go bang with Tippet gone.
Mids look good I have Jack he has a great average against the teams the Swans play for the first few games.

Have you thought of running 5 premo mids plus Ball or Embley someone like Murphy,Fyfe or Mundy for example.

My team thread if you want to have a look the last pic is my current team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71466.0.html

how would you suggest i make get the cash to get the 5th prem mid?

[colmullet]

It looks pretty good man maybe a touch weak in the middle, i guess you could move Cox forward for Buddy and make Goldy your first ruck, that would give you over 100K.....either that or turn Birchall into Yarran if your keen on Pearce and run a weaker backline

[PICCOLLO]

Nice backline I`m seeing Pearce in a few teams now could go bang at the Dockers this season.
Good rucks just keep an eye on Coxy with his finger injury.
I don`t know about Buddy and Roughy the Hawks have a tough start to the year.
Walker could go bang with Tippet gone.
Mids look good I have Jack he has a great average against the teams the Swans play for the first few games.

Have you thought of running 5 premo mids plus Ball or Embley someone like Murphy,Fyfe or Mundy for example.

My team thread if you want to have a look the last pic is my current team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71466.0.html

how would you suggest i make get the cash to get the 5th prem mid?

Five prem mids is a waste IMO. Your spread of money is actually very balanced.

[PICCOLLO]

Viney, omeara and wines look set to play most games.  You could play all 3 on the park i think so 4 premos and a midpricer or 4 and two midpricers is more than enough with Crouch/mitchell/goodes as bench cover.

[ando_10]

yeah think ill leave the mids. seems balanced if i go for 5 prem mids the rest of my side will be unbalanced

[Jessecox10]

Good team I really like the mids keep it the same!! I can't really foult it! 8.9/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71771.0.html rate mine please?

[ubeaut]

Solid. Birchall different to Shaw/Goddard/Gibbs like it. Pearce could do well at Freo.

Ball (or Embley) really fit some teams (not mine) as they make awesome priced M5s. I reckon have a Prem M5 and no mid pricer or have the mid at M5. keep.

Cox much better value as a fwd. i would put him there over Buddy,Roughy or Tex.

[RedCats]

I agree with ubeaut, I would probably look at trying to drop Buddy or Roughy out of the forward line due to the incredibly tough run the Hawks have early in the year, look at moving Cox in to the Forward line and replacing him possibly with Goldstein. A little familiar as everyone seems to be taking that option, but I think it strengthens and balances the forward line a little better.

Staker is the only other, but we all have to deal with that issue now.

Overall, I really like the balance.

Feel free to hit mine up and crucify. Cheers.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71962.0.html

[FactHunt]

I agree with ubeaut, I would probably look at trying to drop Buddy or Roughy out of the forward line due to the incredibly tough run the Hawks have early in the year, look at moving Cox in to the Forward line and replacing him possibly with Goldstein. A little familiar as everyone seems to be taking that option, but I think it strengthens and balances the forward line a little better.

Staker is the only other, but we all have to deal with that issue now.

Overall, I really like the balance.

Feel free to hit mine up and crucify. Cheers.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71962.0.html

Am confused RedCats... you just advised ubeaut to pick up Buddy when you rated his team... which is it?!!!?
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71575.0.html

[RedCats]

I agree with ubeaut, I would probably look at trying to drop Buddy or Roughy out of the forward line due to the incredibly tough run the Hawks have early in the year, look at moving Cox in to the Forward line and replacing him possibly with Goldstein. A little familiar as everyone seems to be taking that option, but I think it strengthens and balances the forward line a little better.

Staker is the only other, but we all have to deal with that issue now.

Overall, I really like the balance.

Feel free to hit mine up and crucify. Cheers.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71962.0.html

Am confused RedCats... you just advised ubeaut to pick up Buddy when you rated his team... which is it?!!!?
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71575.0.html

My bad, more to the point, I wouldn't want to have two Hawthorn Forwards in my side come the start of the year. Personally, I would look at getting rid of Roughead long before I would consider getting rid of Buddy.

[Whippet]

I like the balance of your side - I was looking for the holes and there aren't many.

I'm not sold on Buddy or Walker in the forward line, and would think to make Buddy an upgrade target....

The Staker issue is the only other one, for all of us!

8.5/10

[barnsey70]

like back line like mids dont like rucks and fwd line is ok... upgrade the rucks get sandman
7/10