Rate my side please :) Need some help

[arbel]

Backs: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, G. Birchall, J. Pittard, S. Dochert, D. Terlich .......... J. Thurlow, D. Van Unen
Mids: D. Swan, S. Pendlebury, J. Kennedy, S. Mitchell, N. Fyfe, K. Stevens, B. Crouch, J. Vinney .......... M. Jones, J. O'meara
Rucks: D. Cox, T. Goldstein .......... S. Rowe, D. Currie
Fwds: L. Franklin, N. Reiwoldt, D. Martin, T. Cloke, J. Kennedy, B. Staker .......... T. Menzel, B. Macaffer
Salary Remaining: $80,500

Pretty happy with most, i know my FWDS are my weak link, i just don't like any fwds this yaer, so many that are injury prone, got hot and cold. I know I have Cloke i'm just thinking with Lynch there he might get some fire taken away from him. Then Martin and Reiwoldt are iffy as well, but all others that i think of, chapman, bartel, goodes etc are all qusetionable too ... need some help. What would you do????

[GM]

Hi Mate,
Backs look sound
Mids look ok,i would look at stevens to wines & upgrading Sammy to Ablett or Cotchin perhaps.
Rucks-good but if berger is right to go he should be in there at R2 or R3.Rowe?perhaps Gorringe instead.
Fwd-look good to me as definite pod but i would have to get Rocky in there.Staker could be out til rd3,so watch.

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Looks good 3 Premiums seems to be popular.
Mids: The only question mark is nat Fyfe is he worth keeping or upgrading to someone like Shuey or A. Swallow
Ruck: Very Solid 2 premium Ruck combination
Fwds: Replace Riewoldt with Roughead or Rockliff other than that your team looks ok. May want to replace Staker  as i don't think he will play to at least round 2

I give your Team a 7.5/10

[tor01doc]

Rowe only required if you have Cox in front.

Since you don't, or Ball, for that matter, get another rookie Rucker who will more likely get games. Or put Cox forward into F1.

Buddy out for Cox ( that hurts ) to make Rowe useful and save a few dollars to get rid of NRoo ( I think he is better referred to as JRoo's cousin isn't be? ).

Then seriously look at a top line R1 - Ryder / Sandi / McEvoy / Jacobs / Roughead - all better than Goldy IMO - and Leue?

Traditionally SC favours the little men so to go with Buddy, Cloke and NRoo is risky.

A few tweaks and you'll have a more solid team I reckon.