Shuey v Redden

[pikla]

last dilemma i have for now is my m5 position. Both players are a chance of stepping it up again this year, just a matter of who will step up more?

[Escapist]

To be honest, I dont think you can go wrong with either. I think Redden is a safer option as I remember Shuey missing some games through injury whereas Redden played the whole season (If i'm not mistaken.) I also think externally, Redden will improve more- the lions side has gotten a whole lot stronger with incoming top rookies/new recruits (such as Moloney)- The eagles side hasnt changed much, that being said the eagles are a stronger side either way.

I'd go Redden, shown to play every game and with a better lions side may take his game a little higher than Shuey's.

[m1tch robo]

Redden

[tbagrocks]

I don't like either, sure Reds could step up his contested ball and tacking (if possible) in an improving Lions, the Shue could go big also, but you will need 116+ to be a top 8 mid so are these guys doing this?

I'll take a 112-114 from a smokie but are these guys that somkie? I have doubts

[SydneyRox]

I don't like either, sure Reds could step up his contested ball and tacking (if possible) in an improving Lions, the Shue could go big also, but you will need 116+ to be a top 8 mid so are these guys doing this?

I'll take a 112-114 from a smokie but are these guys that somkie? I have doubts

tbag is right in you need to be sure who you pick can get up to those numbers. i am not sure about either but think redden has the best shot at it

[Ricochet]

I don't like either, sure Reds could step up his contested ball and tacking (if possible) in an improving Lions, the Shue could go big also, but you will need 116+ to be a top 8 mid so are these guys doing this?

I'll take a 112-114 from a smokie but are these guys that somkie? I have doubts

tbag is right in you need to be sure who you pick can get up to those numbers. i am not sure about either but think redden has the best shot at it

Yep have to say i agree here.

Whats the rest of your mids look like Pikia

[pikla]

I don't like either, sure Reds could step up his contested ball and tacking (if possible) in an improving Lions, the Shue could go big also, but you will need 116+ to be a top 8 mid so are these guys doing this?

I'll take a 112-114 from a smokie but are these guys that somkie? I have doubts

tbag is right in you need to be sure who you pick can get up to those numbers. i am not sure about either but think redden has the best shot at it

Yep have to say i agree here.

Whats the rest of your mids look like Pikia

My midfield at the moment is Ablett, Pendles, Cotchin, Murphy, Shuey/Redden, Crouch, O'meara, Viney (Hrovat, K Mitchell)

I do, however, already have 4 lions (Docherty, Burger, Rockliff, Staker) as compared to one eagle (Cox)

[shorty3264]

I think Shuey will average around 115, Redden 110. Can't really lose though

[dmac07]

I'd go redden just because I think he will get a larger share of the lions mids score, compared to shirt in a tough eagles midfield. Still only a few points in it bit I personally wouldn't take either. Think Mindy and fyfe have the same scoring potential and cheaper.

[Jroo]

Redden, he's a gun. Can handle a tag better than Shuey and now has Berger back and Moloney, which will help him

[Shihan7]

Redden for me. He's had two consistently good years in a row and he's ready to go bang.