Attempt 392nd..

[dkennedy]

$16, 900 left over. I have gone for a unique in Watts because I feel he will score well if he plays that rebounding defensive role for Melbourne. I've selected 4 midprices (Pederson, Ball, Leunberger and Byrnes) which well hopefully allow me to upgrade to premiums more easily. Rookie selections still a little unknown. Let me know what you think  ;D

[dkennedy]

anyone want to rate me?

[colmullet]

looks pretty good mate. Have a ? over Pedersen and where he will fit into Melbourne, if up forward he might not see to much of it. Also i think batting 4 prems, fyfe and ball together in the middle is much due to all the great rookie opportunities in the middle this year

If it were me i would drop one of Fyfe/Ball and upgrade Pedersen

[dkennedy]

looks pretty good mate. Have a ? over Pedersen and where he will fit into Melbourne, if up forward he might not see to much of it. Also i think batting 4 prems, fyfe and ball together in the middle is much due to all the great rookie opportunities in the middle this year

If it were me i would drop one of Fyfe/Ball and upgrade Pedersen

Yeah I'm not 100% on Pederson. It all depends on what role he plays, if he can play that Stefan Martin second ruck role or that rebounding defender then he may average more than his price suggests. I guess we'll have to see in the NAB Cup. Yeah I have considered going 3 rookie mids starting, but then I also thought Ball would average more and make around the same amount of cash. I'll see, if one rookie mid stands out I may end up downgrading Ball. Cheers for the advice.

[tor01doc]

Not many Essendon players (can't count St Brendan yet as he hasn't played)?

Agree with too many mids leaving rookies short.

Also leaves you with a weaker forward line than many posted.

Rucks = Toyota Corolla!

Martin worries me because he has so much potential - but when?

I like your project players too.

I would ditch Fyfe for a rookie and upgrade your rucks and forward line.

Good luck and I hope you don't drive a Corolla!

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Good Unique Pick in Jack Watts should have have a. Downgrade Pederson to Terlich
MIDS: Probably too strong Ithink you should Downgrade Luke Ball to Wines or Lonergan or even Mayes and upgrade Fyfe to a Premium.
Rucks: Standard
Fwds: Solid hopefully Martin goes better as he seem to have top 1st halfs and disappear after half time.


Overall: Well Balanced team which needs 1 extra premium in the midfield as i don't think Fyfe is quite in the Elite Bracket yet. I give your team an 8/10

[dkennedy]

I've gone Ball------>Lonergan
              Fyfe----->Selwood
              Goldstein>Jacobs

[tor01doc]

Much betterer!