Supercoach team 2, promising or destined to fail?

Started by steve_maxwell23, February 21, 2010, 02:40:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

steve_maxwell23

Supercoach team number 2
Ok guys second dig at my sc team, first one was average with the main problem being backs and rucks. Comments would b great guys, really appreciated the ones b4. Say what u thought I did right and what i did wrong, and any tips i could do to improve or change the lineup.
Cheers! ;D

Hawka10 Sc team

With $11,000 left in the bank

BACKS
S.Fisher
L.Hodge
A.Carrazzo
J.Macdonald
N.Krakouer (or Kenelly?)
R.Ladson (Hunt?)
B.Waters (To risky?)
EMG:
B.Sheppard
M.Maguire


Midfield:

G.Ablett
S.Pendlebury
B.Vince
A.Cooney
J.Trengrove
D.Martin
* Or maybe downgrade a premium for either Burgoyne(when fit and playing), M.Mcveigh(will have better 2010 then 2009) or David Armitage?
EMG:
R.Bastinic
J.Kayler-Thompson

Rucks:
H.Mcintosh
N.Naitanui
EMG:
J.Charman (will increase in price then i'll trade him)
W.Skipper( will play regular senior footy, or get rid of him for trengrove and spend money left over to upgrade a forward?)
*Brad Ottens: sc steal if he gets fit and playing?

Forwards:

R'OKeefe
S.Johnson (if fit)
L.Franklin
D.Giansiracusa
B.Hall(better supply=more goals and sc points?, Or P.Medhurst,J.Kennedy, P.Dangerfield?)
A.Buchanan (advice i got from my other post)
J.Ziebell
EMG:
T.Rockliff(impressive in nab cup or maybe get someone else?)
J.Podsiadly


Alright guys tear this team to pieces and tell us what u think

bjrouse

Backs I would play the bracketed players.

I think your two bench rookies are wrong. Other than that the mids are exceptional

Ok rucks. Not sold on Nic Nac from NAB. No strong competition and no Cox

Play Dangerfield over Hall

cozza123

you just copied and pasted my team didnt ya? lol, i wouldnt have carrazzo(more of a dt player), Naitanui( one hit wonder in nab cup. wont do that again when cox comes back), hall, Armitage(if he was 50k-60k cheaper than yes i would get him) and franklin is an overweight stray

steve_maxwell23

Quote from: bjrouse on February 22, 2010, 02:07:23 AM
Backs I would play the bracketed players.

I think your two bench rookies are wrong. Other than that the mids are exceptional

Ok rucks. Not sold on Nic Nac from NAB. No strong competition and no Cox

Play Dangerfield over Hall

So play kenelly and hunt? Are u tlkin about the two bench rookies in the midfield or what position? Who should i replace for them as i only have $11,000 left. Yeah I was thinkin P.Dangerfield up forward but who would u recommend that i swap Nic Nac for? should i downgrade w.skipper and use the money to upgrade him?
Appreciate the feedback champ

steve_maxwell23

Quote from: cozza123 on February 22, 2010, 02:44:29 AM
you just copied and pasted my team didnt ya? lol, i wouldnt have carrazzo(more of a dt player), Naitanui( one hit wonder in nab cup. wont do that again when cox comes back), hall, Armitage(if he was 50k-60k cheaper than yes i would get him) and franklin is an overweight stray

Yeah i only had carrazzo for the time being, looking for a better replacement. Only got Nic Nac coz of price and i think he'll do well. Armitage will rise in price, he was impressive the other night and we'll be in midfield with Ball going to pies plus he is only an option so i make some cash. Franklin is a star and C.Mooney is the worst footballer in the history of the game!

bigboppa

with your theory on brad ottens i agree.. he only played 3 games last year and averaged something like 87. this year he has finally completed a full pre-season down at the cattery (besides hurting his hand, which still allowed him to train). If he stays fit and  injury free then i think he will be an extremely good buy at 371 000

steve_maxwell23

Quote from: bigboppa on February 22, 2010, 04:22:34 AM
with your theory on brad ottens i agree.. he only played 3 games last year and averaged something like 87. this year he has finally completed a full pre-season down at the cattery (besides hurting his hand, which still allowed him to train). If he stays fit and  injury free then i think he will be an extremely good buy at 371 000

True mate, if he stays fit and injury free lol

cozza123