Which star?

[lowry]

Having trouble which one to choose, Cotchin seems to be the popular one, would Deledio be a POD?

[Jroo]

Cotchin will out score him by a little.
But if your looking for a POD Lids wouldn't be so bad.
Personally I'd pick Cotch and then put someone like JP Kennedy for a POD

[quinny88]

Both ultra consistent and I think will both increase their averages again in 2013.
Deledio would create a great POD. Have not seen any teams with him yet

[dmac07]

Cotchin has a little more upside. But lately starting to go away from the thought he is a must have for some reason. Deledio could well be a good POD from all those people with Cotchin (myself included). Though Selwood, Watson, Boyd, Beams could all provide the same POD

[Colliwobblers]

Cotchin still on the improve and has something super special about him. I think he will reach true elite level where delidio like gibbs like so many others will be, IS very premium, i just think cotchin will hit the true elite  level so few do in the game.

[thewizz]

Have cotch, could have gone lids, happy to have them both at tigerland!

[SydneyRox]

Lids is the proven option

[tbagrocks]

Lids to be in front at the bye, the oveer hyped Cotch is an upgrade target

[brownmans muffins]

Tricky one but you'd almost go Cotch due to weight of numbers & fight the POD battle elsewhere

lids available in Def was so good last year -sighs

[lowry]

thanks guys, i reckon cotch is a must-have since i have a pretty unique team anyway :)