rate my side pic !!!

[barnsey70]

[JMAN23]

defence: to weak in my opinion, would get rid of a premium midfeilder and look to get gibbs or shaw in there for thurlow maybe.
mid: probably to much money invested in this spot. i personally would take swan out (usually takes him a few rounds to get going) and upgrade a rookie defender to a premium. and maybe get viney, crouch or put mitchel in your team as they should play most games and make you money.
ruck: havent seen to many with 2 premium ruckman, be wary about sandilands, very injury prone, hopefully get stays fit, will be the best ruckman in league.
forwards: not strong enough, with money left over from swan trade would upgrade byrnes to wright if you can afford him, probably will have to do a few extra trades to make this team work.
This is all my opinion, will rate 6/10 :)

[barnsey70]

i see where your coming from but the way i look at it.. there are no blokes in the backline that will average 120+ other than goddard and im taking a punt on broughton and he at best will avg 110
ruckmen score huge... hince the fact i have 3 in there not just the 2...
and given the fact looking at everyones side has 12-13 premiums i have 13 and they will all avg 110 onwards

thoughts ??

[JMAN23]

i think gibbs will have a red hot crack this year under mick and score big.
and i think your punt on the ruckman is good, wish i had enough salary to do it!

[barnsey70]

out of the 13 400k plus players ive got only 2 of them d.martin & g.broughton there is a question over whether they can step up to 100+ avg.  also midfielders are going to be much harder to upgrade given the new $$$ strategy... they will all be over or around 600k... imo there is no proven backman that will avg 110+ a week so i have chosen to put  most of the money into the midfield.
thoughts ??

[Freddy]

Honestly you will be losing games with the poor scores in the backline.
I would suggest get rid of one of your premium mids to spend balancing your side.
with many rookies likely to get vested, rested you are bound to get some terrible scores.

Needs 1 less premo mid and 1 more defender mid atleast

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Far too weak need a Premium at D2 & D3 Prefer Gibbs & Birchall.
Mids: Downgrade  Swan or Dangerfield  to Brad Crouch to get the money you need to strengthen your defence & Fwds
Rucks Solid
Fwds: Also Slighly weak here with Martin at F3 upgrade Byrnes to either Hawkins or Wright.

As it stands i give your team a 6.5/10

[Junktimer]

dat defence