Give me as much criticism as needed :)

[BoredSaint]

Literally did this in 5 mins. Give me all the criticism needed

Def: Goddard, Hartlett, Hanley, Fisher, Bock, Staker (Docherty, Colquhoun)

Mid: Ablett, Pendlebury, Watson, Sloane, Fyfe, Wines, Crouch, O'Maera (Hrovat, Viney)

Rucks: Sandilands, Leuenberger (Rowe, Grundy)

Fwd: Naitanui, Rockliff, Broughton, Varcoe, Knights, Mayes (Lee, Membrey)

[kilbluff1985]

Fisher+bock = no

Nic Nat wont be 100% for round 1 if he even plays

Broughton at F3 = no

[mabo]

Bock in doubt for round 1, 29 coming back from a serious injury but his surname isn't Hayes so personally I'm steering clear.

Colquhoun has only just turned 18 and is still very small body wise - won't get many, if any, senior games until he puts some bulk on.

I like your pick of Sloane, looks ready to break his game wide open this year and will be a good unique.

As KB said, NicNat could be a good long way away.

Personally, I'm not sold on Knights insta-making it into Richmond's best 22.

[Keeper27]

Fisher+bock = no

Nic Nat wont be 100% for round 1 if he even plays

Broughton at F3 = no

agreed on all points.

3 premo's (120+) in the mid is a bit short. most teams will have 4. you'll fall behind early.

3 premo's in the FWD/back lines is light too.

[Jay]

Good to see you around BS

Fisher has to go, his fantasy days are done

Mids are fine - very good choices actually

Good to see someone taking a risk on Sandi

NicNat is a no-no and cant see Broughts being worthy of F3

[Ringo]

Welcome mate: No comments on rookies.

Def: Fisher could be an interesting choice with Goddard gone will he fill that role running out or be given a KPP, Similarly Broughton at suns so watch in pre season to gauge roles being filled. Bock is due to start running this week so may be very under done for Round 1 so use as downgrade target later on.
Mids: Very sound choices
Rucks: Sound
Fwds; - Replace Nat with Cox comments on Broughton above. Would like to see another prem in here

Solid Start rating 7.5/10