Trying for top 1000 repeat...please rate

Started by Zabs, January 18, 2013, 12:05:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Zabs

Goddard, Gibbs, Broughton, Birchall, Goodes, Docherty (Heath, Terlich)

Ablett, Swan, Cotchin, Murphy, Mundy, Embley, Crouch, Viney (O'meara, Mitchell)

Cox, Luey (Witts, Daw)

Franklin, Rockliff, Dusty, Sylvia, Staker, Macaffer ( lee, membrey)


Spuds11


Ringo

Solid team first up

Def: Solid prems
Mids: Again solid prems  Not sure of cash situation but as mid pricers prefer Ball to Embley just personal opinion though. (18k difference)
Rucks: Standard
Forwards: Solid - Sylvia will give a rollercoaster ride based on previous years.  With 30 trades however can take this risk.

No comments on rookies as we all will be assessing in NAB cup and selections for Round 1.

Rtae team 8/10

NoButYeah

Agree with Ringo, you'll love or hate Sylvia but we now have more trades, so can be easily fixed. Other than that can't fault anything. Nice side.

Capper

regarding the rookies, it is hard to say who will play round 1 but Goodes is still on the Dogs rookie list and needs to be upgraded to main list but no spots. Another is Mitchell, he is a gun but dont see him getting a game till at least mid year.

Your team is pretty solid, start Silvia, you will learn to love him then hate him.

One thing i would consider is downgrading Embley to a cheaper player and upgrade Mundy or Goodes

nrich102

Looks good Zabs. Not sold on Macaffer, but good other than that.