Broughton vs Goldy

[owenbond007]

Ok looking at moving cox into rucks and outing goldy for greg (in forwards). Just wondering thoughts on who will score the most. If you voted other can you suggest another forward or ruck less than 410k. Thanks

[Windigo]

I'd go Broughton. Reckon he will prosper in his new role at GC.

What "F" possie will Greg be occupying?  ???

[Ricochet]

Its very close between the two but Broughts is a safe 85-90
Goldy could be anything from 80-100
Personally i'd be taking the punt on Goldy. He is only 25 this year and has no HMac to share the work with. Some are talking about Daw and Currie coming in and taking points away from Goldy, but he will still be the #1 ruckman.

[owenbond007]

I'd go Broughton. Reckon he will prosper in his new role at GC.

What "F" possie will Greg be occupying?  ???

F4/5 with the view to move him into the back later if his a success.

[Adamant]

I would go Broughton, I think he'll outscore Goldy by around 5 or so points.

Sylvia is also another very good option at 392k.

[owenbond007]

I would go Broughton, I think he'll outscore Goldy by around 5 or so points.

Sylvia is also another very good option at 392k.

Sylvia is a good DTer when fit and playing , he did play 17 games last year not sure how many times he was subbed, only ave 76. Think he is a bit of a loose unit though massive risk.

[Jukes]

Why has everybody gone off Goldstein recently? Goddamn, a negative article on DT Talk and Dreamers and everybody jumps off because 2 people said he's not good, the peer pressure in the DT community is enormous. Goldy will surely go 92+ if not close to 100 territory. If people only talk about the negatives as they have been doing, Goldy will average 10 if not 5. Has everybody forgotten that last season Goldstein played without consistent injuries (nothing to be worried about, nothing long-term ie sickness) and without another McIntosh he averaged NINETY NINE.

Broughton meanwhile I can't see breaking 91. At his absolute career best so far he's gone 88 in a DT-friendly role, and he won't get that with GAJ, Bennell etc there.

Watch NAB cup form anyway with all the x vs y players.

[Adamant]

I would go Broughton, I think he'll outscore Goldy by around 5 or so points.

Sylvia is also another very good option at 392k.

Sylvia is a good DTer when fit and playing , he did play 17 games last year not sure how many times he was subbed, only ave 76. Think he is a bit of a loose unit though massive risk.

Have a read of this: http://www.afldreamers.com/strategy/rids-never-again-list-colin-sylvia/

[Mr.Craig]

I think there'll only be a few points between them. Both around the 87-90 mark.

[Holz]

I woudl say Goldy + forward replacing cox will outscore Cox + Broughton.

Really though between these two options there isnt much seperating them I woudl say goldy just.

[essendon2]

Sylvia!
if you're after DEF only though, go Broughton or Hanley

[Bones Bombers]

This decisionis very difficult...until Nab cup gives us something to go by.
For me its a choice between Goldy and Dusty. :-\