AXV No1, who would you have

[tbagrocks]

Who would you take if had the AXV No 1 pick?

Nails, after a long, long week took Buddy

Let's see who was the most popular pick!

Please disgard this years scoring ???

[Jroo]

Ablett or Pendles for me.
Ablett is a better scorer but Pendles is younger  :-\
Probably just Ablett.

[Adamant]

Hard to say tbh. At the time, I didn't have much SB scoring knowledge and didn't realise how valuable Key position forwards were, so definitely wouldn't have taken Buddy.

Was always going for short term glory, so would've taken Swanny, Ablett or Pendles. I think at the time I would've taken Swan, but a week into drafting I realised age is also still important, so Pendles would've been good.

[Noz]

Probably Ablett

[Toga]

I would've gone Ablett. He's a big reason why the Dolphins are on top right now!

[Justin Bieber]

Would of gone Abo for sure.

[Memphistopheles]

I'd take Gary Ablett

[tbagrocks]

Tell ya what I would have been tempted by Beams, but then locked GAJ almost as soon as I could've :P

P.s Nails, this is not a thread about your dumb pick :P Just curious to see what might have happened :)

[Colliwobblers]

I have him Dayne Beams.

But for everyone and anyone who wants immediate success there is no comparison to Ablett, Swan can match him, but hasn't this season. May close the gap over the run home....

[Ricochet]

I probably still would have taken Buddy or Pendles

[Nails]

Buddy was only averaging 6 less than GAJ when we selected him but he had a bad few games to end the season and dropped right off.

A 25yo keyforward who's a MILE above the rest vs. a midfielder where you can replace him with other 135-140 averages..

A 29yo vs. 25yo key forward where key forward averages 6 less..

Easy on the GAJ vs. Franklin front.