Which defender?

Started by Bedlam, August 09, 2012, 01:01:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Best value for money defender under $439k

Birchall
11 (73.3%)
Grimes
2 (13.3%)
Adcock
1 (6.7%)
Fisher
1 (6.7%)
Other (please specify)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Bedlam

Current backs:
Deledio / H Shaw / M Johnson / Scotland / Lake / Goddard / Spurr / Wrigley / ?

5 trades (1 more this round)

tbagrocks

I'd go Grimes, the boys on fire and appears to be getting better (certainly fantacy wise) as the year goes on

Samm79

Birchall by a reasonable distance, Fisher next. Proven premiums.

Adamant

Birch for me with Grimes a close second.

aces-high

Birch is a lock out of those! Very consistent and is a durable performer. Grimes is more of a dt'er. I think birch will defs score the most out of those options bud :)

The Bomber

Birchall with effective disposals.

Fisher a proven premium under performing and Grimes equal second by a body length...

fever

birchall far and above the others listed

demon_spud

A lot of love for Birchall, considering his last 2 games were well below par, but could average 100s for the rest of the season.

Sure he has two easy games coming up next, but if you need to rely on him in the finals, he has WCE and SYD.

Didn't play them this year, (missed both matches), however he did smash them the previous year. (113, 146).

Maybe rested in the last few games at some stage, perhaps this week or the next, not for the tougher ones come Semis and Granny.