Which defender should be shown the pine?

[Fumble Ball]

Def: Lids, Gods, Hurn, Enright, Yarran, Dempsey, Bagels, S Shaw,(Boots)

Need to show someone vest and be on the pine,

Reality it's either Dempsey 74avg, S Shaw 73avg or Bagels 72avg.
Hard to split them but I feel S Shaw and Bagels are the hungriest.

Thoughts Chaps?

[Blues Blues Blues]

Stick stinky Dempsey on the pine.

Having said that I am thinking of trading Dempsey out this week. If I do he will score 100 guaranteed. If I don't trade him he'll squeeze out another turd of a performance.

[Fumble Ball]

More info

1 trade left & need it for emergency or trade a def late in finals.
Sitting 22453 overall so it's no consequence there, but happy as this is my second year playing.

Main league- Sitting second on ladder, 4 points of first, if 1st losses, which is a chance & I win (playin 14th) it should put me in 1st on %.
If I lose the worst I can Finish is 3rd.

Othe league win go to 4th/loss I finish 6th