Waters or carrots

[yates]

Replacment for broughton!
Already have deledio, Goddard, shaw, enright, Scotland, lake.
I have the choice of anyone.
Please let me know which one you would take.
Thanks a lot!!

[jfitty]

That's a tough one! I reckon I would take Waters though. In career best form in a top 4 (almost) team. Plus you save yourself 10k or so. But it's really a coin flip.

[HappyDEZ]

Very hard to split 'em. It would be nice to have 'em both. If you have Baguley on your MID bench, in that case Carrots for sure.

[Spinking]

Very tough.  Both have been very solid this year, but both can go missing when doing a job on someone.  I'd say Waters but only just.

[The Bomber]

No love for carrots? I'd vote him because of durability. Close to the end and you don't want to waste a trade and then the player gets injured. Waters more prone to that...

[yates]

cant decide on these 2. its a tough one. still undecided, and dont think i will until just before lock out

[Blues Blues Blues]

Carrots for mine, has been so consistent since coming back