Waters or carrots

Started by yates, August 02, 2012, 04:27:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

yates

Replacment for broughton!
Already have deledio, Goddard, shaw, enright, Scotland, lake.
I have the choice of anyone.
Please let me know which one you would take.
Thanks a lot!!

jfitty

That's a tough one! I reckon I would take Waters though. In career best form in a top 4 (almost) team. Plus you save yourself 10k or so. But it's really a coin flip.

HappyDEZ

Very hard to split 'em. It would be nice to have 'em both. If you have Baguley on your MID bench, in that case Carrots for sure.

Spinking

Very tough.  Both have been very solid this year, but both can go missing when doing a job on someone.  I'd say Waters but only just.

The Bomber

No love for carrots? I'd vote him because of durability. Close to the end and you don't want to waste a trade and then the player gets injured. Waters more prone to that...

yates

cant decide on these 2. its a tough one. still undecided, and dont think i will until just before lock out

Blues Blues Blues

Carrots for mine, has been so consistent since coming back