Last trade - Stanton???

Started by pinochio, August 02, 2012, 07:54:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

pinochio

To use or not to use?

Stanton > Murphy???

here are my benches:
DEF (ellis/shaw)
MID (jmac/gibson)
Ruck (redden/bigO)
FOR (murdoch/treloar)

other option is to wait out stantons hammy and play gibson??


Spinking

It is a good looking trade and it's unlikely you'll get another chance to get Murphy again at this price, but there is a big risk using your last trade with 4 weeks to go. I wouldn't do it myself, but your bench cover is good so you may be able to cover injuries when they come up.

Bak2Form

#2
1 trade left u gotta hold. Gibson will score the same as Stanton would have anyway

pinochio

good point guys!

gibson will prob score more then stants anyway....
but murphy will skyrocket starting this round, might not be able to get a super premo anymore this year...

thoughts?

Bak2Form

i just think the chance of you not coping another injury between now and end of finals is almost nil. the trade will prob be needed and used better in the long run. as much as i dont like Stanton he has proved he can score huge so maybe sit tight and let gibson take over for a week or 2 until he comes back. Murph is a great option but only if you have the trades todo it

pinochio

ye probs gonna play a gibbo and hold stants! :)

Ajax22

No way! If you can play a full team at this point then that's what you do. No trades except to cover donuts with 1 trade left. What happens if one of your ruckmen go down? You would likely have no cover at all.
There's also no guarantee Murphy will score that amazing anyway since he'll be copping most of the attention from other teams

pinochio

thx fellas, bought me down to earth :)

of course ill hold stants :P