please hav a look i would be very appreciative and i would rate you as a legend

[starz]

keen to find out what everyone thinks about this.

goddard
shaw
fish
hodge
kennelly
ladson
hunt

trengrove
davis

abblett
pendles
coon
masten
trengrove
martin

banner
shuey

sandi
tippet- need help

lobbe
roughy

roo
pav
higgins
franklin
ziebell
danger
hitchcok-help needed

gumby/tdl
pods

[Jenko]

masten is not supercoach gold he can run all day but his ball use is wat lets him down therefore no big scores, tippet is in for a big year there is no doubt

[Swansational]

I agree with Jenko on Masten. You really need to do something about Hitchcock as well. You could take a punt on a first year player but thats very risky. Other things you could do is downgrade abblett for another less expensive mid who will still score you 100's or you could jump on rockliff after his NAB cup performance. Thats also a risk though. I like Tippett he will be a gun if he can get some consistency in his game

[starz]

masten to burguone. or is burguone not a good option from the start.

don't know much about rockliff but i don't think he will play much midfield with the likes of power and black coing back

[Swansational]

Burgoyne is risky as well because he has had some surgery over the break and i'm not sure he will be at 100% fitness by rd 1. Everyone is jumping on Rockliff because he scored 142 on the weekend but he hasnt played much AFL before that. Still could be one to watch if he keeps it up

[starz]

being a swans supporter you should be able to tell me if malcski is worth getting i read a very nice article about him in the tele.

do you think this backline is too weak:
god
shaw
hodge
kennely
mal
ladson
hunt

[Swansational]

I like your backline a lot actually. Malceski is definately worth the gamble. I don't reckon he was 100% last year because of the surgery he had the previous year and you could tell he was struggling. I reckon he will be much more consistent this year. Josh Hunt is a great pick up too very good sc player

[Crushemall]

Hey I think you've got some work to do

Although I love, Hodge, Ladson, Cooney and Dangerfield

I have a prob firstly with kennelly he apparently never scored that well b4 so really an ok cheaper buy if he has freshened up and has all the skills back, Ablett I am banking on dropping in value with the loss of Harley and further over tagging, I think the combo of Mastern, Trengove and Martin is 1 too many and would say get rid of martin and fin a mid mid to take his place maybe drop franklin too and find a mid forward like Morton or Williams to fill the void.

BTW instead of Tippett how about Charman and you have more money for your point earning midfield

[ronl]

I know Port has problems but do you think they would really play 4 rookies?
They just might, I suppose, and you've left out Paul Stewart who might be the best of them.