Stanton vs Lake

Started by Barra17, July 29, 2012, 10:58:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Barra17

Who should I get rid of? I hear Stants may be under injury cloud. These 2 are my worst players on the field and want to upgrade.

If I went Stanton I could go to Murphy (Mids: Swan, GAJ, Jelwood, Boyd, Thompson)

Or

Lake to someone under 415k (Backs: Goddard, Lids, Grimes, Carrazzo, Scotland, Waters)

Colliwobblers

i would do stanton you need the elite mid more than the defender.

such a shame he has dropped to rockliffs level after starting so well.


Spinking

I'd trade Stanton - you've already got all the best defs. Murphy would look good in that midfield.

fertalong

Definitely drop stanton for murphy

Fireballz


Colliwobblers

i would go pendles over watson both before murphy for DT.

Barra17

I've only got 477,800 to spend :(

aces-high

Get murphy man! Stants in a slump and may miss time with an apparent tight left hammy. Lake should bounce back after a stinker today. Players playing injured especially with tight muscles struggle badly!

HBTD22

Wait to see the teams this week for Stants. If hes in I'd keep him.

Ajax22

Quote from: HBTD22 on July 30, 2012, 10:58:19 AM
Wait to see the teams this week for Stants. If hes in I'd keep him.

Agreed, not sure I see Murphy doing all that much better than Stants.
Birchall in for Lake could be a decent option. Otherwise Sucklings at some great value

knobjob

Essendon is also playing the twilight game on Sunday after playing the Friday night the week before.  That's a good rest and I'd expect him to loosen up after a 9 day rest.