Is my idea the right one?

[jamesalex]

What do people think i should do for trades his round? Heres the team:

Defence: Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Hurn, Suckling, Malceski, Lake (S.Shaw, Darley)
Midfield: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Boyd, Thompson, Horsely (Mcdonald, Gibson)
Rucks: Naitanui, Mumford (Stephenson, Campbell)
Forwards Franklin, Beams, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Goodes, Martin, Zorko (Treloar, Adams)

4 TRADES LEFT,  $86,800 in the bank

Any ideas?
The orginal plan was to downgrade Mcdonakd to Baguley and upgrade Horse to Pendles  this round, but i cant afford it.
I can do Adams/Treloar and Horsely/Mcdonald to Couch and Pendles respectively though.
Or.. I could wait a week for Sam Shaw to go up (BE of -9), downgrade him to Baguley and then upgrade Horse/Pendles, providong they dont go down too much.

Any other ideas?

Trade this round, which leaves me with 2 trades (which is risky) or hold? (which is also risky, as Horse/Mcdonakd could go down by too much.)

Thanks.

[Capper]

I dont know how many more games JMAC will play. Obviously one more for his farewell but thats it i think.

How short of cash are you of you trade JMAC for Couch and Horsley to Pendles??

[jamesalex]

I dont know how many more games JMAC will play. Obviously one more for his farewell but thats it i think.

How short of cash are you of you trade JMAC for Couch and Horsley to Pendles??

Im about 16k short.

[tor01doc]

Can your itchy trade finger wait a week?

Hopefully JMac does not play. No loss there.

Pendles has a high BE so might actually drop a few
K. Also vs the mighty Hawks he may not score huge. Here's hoping anyway.

Couch has another week I think.

That leaves Horsely's predicted drop in price your main worry assuming he plays.

Could you do Horsley to Couch this week if JMac is rested and then afford Pendles the following week?

[jamesalex]

Can your itchy trade finger wait a week?

Hopefully JMac does not play. No loss there.

Pendles has a high BE so might actually drop a few
K. Also vs the mighty Hawks he may not score huge. Here's hoping anyway.

Couch has another week I think.

That leaves Horsely's predicted drop in price your main worry assuming he plays.

Could you do Horsley to Couch this week if JMac is rested and then afford Pendles the following week?

i need Pendles to.drop around 15-16k..

[Capper]

in SC Gold pendles BE of 146 estimated drop of 12K

[jamesalex]

in SC Gold pendles BE of 146 estimated drop of 12K

Dont want to risk that. Any other thoughts?

[The Bomber]

Adams --> Rookie
McDonald --> Pendles?

[jamesalex]

Adams --> Rookie
McDonald --> Pendles?

Yes, I can do that, however I would preferably want to wait a week for Couch/Baguley if possible. What do you think?

[The Bomber]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,65041.0.html
Baugley vs Brown vs Couch

If you skim over it is a consensus with 1. Baugley, 2. Couch, 3. Brown.

Also add Yeo to the mix and Clifton and you have quite a few options.

Clifton is a pretty secure bet to play out the season. But he isn't DPP and is 130k.
Yeo -> Ask Ringo
Baugley -> JS gets better with every injury we (the dons) have.
Couch -> God only knows
Brown -> Won't hold his spot IMO

Personally I would want the points. 1 more week (given they are all named) isn't going to help your decision so you may as well get some extra points from doing the trades this week...

[Ringo]

With both Merrett and Rich suspended I expect Yeo to keep his spot.  Yeo repl;aced McKeever last week and whilst not outstanding was ok. 
Only challenge will be Docherty who is really now finding some form in the reserves.

[jamesalex]

I'm going for league and it doesn't look like i'm in any hurry for points judging by this weeks opponent.. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=other_teams&lid=1&tid=228963