Franklin to Goodes??

Started by dillez, July 09, 2012, 11:23:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

dillez

I know we shouldn't trade out the star but i am planning on getting in Goodes anyway, if I do this I make $150k and then bring him back for porp later?

What do u think?

Colliwobblers

good luck to you if you have so many trades left to consider this, but with waters out for a month pendles having been out for a month, suspensions running wild, what makes you think it wont happen again to a player you have?

can you afford to trade him in and out and still have trades for if anything else goes wrong, ala martin and goddard suspended waters out for a month....

what is next!

still if you have the trades goodes at his price isnt crazy, getting rid of buddy tho might be a little short sighted, but would give you a chance to gain rank while "most" other teams keep him on the bench and play a rook instead.

KoopKicka

Quote from: Colliwobblers on July 09, 2012, 11:26:41 PM
good luck to you if you have so many trades left to consider this, but with waters out for a month pendles having been out for a month, suspensions running wild, what makes you think it wont happen again to a player you have?

can you afford to trade him in and out and still have trades for if anything else goes wrong, ala martin and goddard suspended waters out for a month....

what is next!

still if you have the trades goodes at his price isnt crazy, getting rid of buddy tho might be a little short sighted, but would give you a chance to gain rank while "most" other teams keep him on the bench and play a rook instead.

Basically this, wish I had the trades to spare, and Ive got Crozier and Sexton on my forward bench. FMDT

MLS

All benches are going to be tested this week. Unless you have trades to burn, a 2-3 week injury probably isn't worth the extra trade to get him back in.

Haddy1.0

I will be doing this trade and getting him back in for the finals.
With 9 trades left I think I can afford to use the extra one to get him back later.

Spuds11

if you do this franlin want drop away like the others you have to rebuy at top dollar

charliesheen

Quote from: Haddy1.0 on July 09, 2012, 11:39:26 PM
I will be doing this trade and getting him back in for the finals.
With 9 trades left I think I can afford to use the extra one to get him back later.

Why not use another trade to get another fwd and increase bench size?

KoopKicka

Quote from: Haddy1.0 on July 09, 2012, 11:39:26 PM
I will be doing this trade and getting him back in for the finals.
With 9 trades left I think I can afford to use the extra one to get him back later.

9!?!?!?!? :O

Artax

Quote from: Haddy1.0 on July 09, 2012, 11:39:26 PM
I will be doing this trade and getting him back in for the finals.
With 9 trades left I think I can afford to use the extra one to get him back later.

With 9 I would do it. I have 7 and will probably go Dusty to Goodes to avoid 2 premos on the bench.. if you can even call Dusty that..Schmuck

SydneyRox

If you have 9, then it is a good idea IMO.

Windigo

Yeah, with enough trades go for it.  ;)

dillez

heres my side, i have 7 trades left and no cash in the bank

DEF: B Deledio (105), H Scotland (83), G Broughton (59), J Adcock (111), H Shaw (77), B Ellis (72), A Carrazzo (114), B Goddard (0), S Shaw (74)

MID: M Boyd (133), D Swan (105), G Ablett (104), S Mitchell (106), J Redden (66), S Gibson (79), A Miles (0), T Couch (0)

RUCK: D Cox (148), J Giles (48), J Redden (0), T Campbell (38)

FWD: S Sidebottom (94), L Franklin (72), D Beams (78), M Robinson (109), M Pavlich (144), J Porplyzia (74), D Zorko (140), D Martin (0), A Hall (0)

I am still gonna bring in goodes this week? how would u do it or what would u do instead?


Artax

I'd trade Martin over Franklin

DT Gun

I think buddy will struggle on the run home.. dont think he will outscore goodes/pav and even if he does it wont be by much

SydneyRox

7 trades isnt a lot. So it all depends on your main league situation.

If you are going to make the finals hold tight with both Buddy and Martin

Trade Couch to Mcintyre, which is a bit of a waste, but having two non playing, non dpp rookies on your mid bench is worse.

If you are going to struggle to make the finals then you need to act. Trade Buddy to Goodes and still do Couch to McIntyre this week and next week use the cash to upgrade Gibson to finish your midfield. Should leave you with a decent team and 4 trades which you can use for LTI's