playing elliott over petrie

[me]

is this stupid?

normally i would play petrie over elliott, but the roos have the eagles down in tassie, so im really not expecting great output from petrie against a tough eagles defense (darren glass)

eliotts shown pretty good (tackling) form, so if he can get a bit more of the pill and possible jag a few in a magpie rout of the blues - could be worth the risk?

[oldshepp]

I would never play a rookie willingly over a semi-premium

Both could get you 65 true but then Petrie could smash 100 plus too

Elliott unlikely to do the same

[Lucky1972]

yeh thats stupid dude - petrie will get 105 tomoz

[TheHanger]

Elliot has hit 90+ twice out of 5 games?

Pretty good odds but doubt he can get 15 tackles again and that gave him 2/3 of his points last week

PETRIE

[Artax]

Not crazy but you need to back your premo

[MyPies]

Elliot is the sub

[TheHanger]

Elliot is the sub

Sinclair is isn't he?

[Thunderstruck]

Petrie is Semi Prem and would advise to play him over any rookie any day....

[its me lads]

come on mate, petrie any day

[me]

alright, going to go petrie but would just about put money on elliott outscoring him this week

time will tell...

cheers fellas

[TheHanger]

lucky you asked and listened (hopefully)

[its me lads]

lucky you asked and listened (hopefully)

+1