Scotland vs swan

Started by formula16, July 03, 2012, 06:20:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

formula16

Who should i get first?

zorko > swan

or

ellis > scotland

they are the last premium in their respective lines in my team

thanks!

Chelskiman

I think Ellis > Scotland first, only cause Zorko has the ability to score a ton.  Swan is the better player by far, but I think Ellis > Scotland is a more important trade.

chrisuzz

Quote from: Chelskiman on July 03, 2012, 06:37:47 PM
I think Ellis > Scotland first, only cause Zorko has the ability to score a ton.  Swan is the better player by far, but I think Ellis > Scotland is a more important trade.
+1

Thunderstruck

Quote from: Chelskiman on July 03, 2012, 06:37:47 PM
I think Ellis > Scotland first, only cause Zorko has the ability to score a ton.  Swan is the better player by far, but I think Ellis > Scotland is a more important trade.

In the scenario presented I have to agree with Chelski on this.

Windigo

Getting Swan is a must.

But ousting Ellis for Scotland is the best trade.  ;)

yorgis

zorko and gibbo would be great benchies and reasonably good scorers . swan and scotland are obviously better but a it would be

a shame to let them go

powersuperkents

Quote from: Chelskiman on July 03, 2012, 06:37:47 PM
I think Ellis > Scotland first, only cause Zorko has the ability to score a ton.  Swan is the better player by far, but I think Ellis > Scotland is a more important trade.
Fair call Ellis is useless and in this scenario Scotland just wins, but still try to bring in Swan in a few weeks or so!! he is the greatest DT player in history like seriously a 130 average!!!! I don't know why I chose Ablett over Swanny for the Captaincy last week!!