Ruck dilemma..anyone else in the same boat?

[Mr Adams]

Have Maric and Mummy (Giles, Redden)

8 trades left. Need cash for final upgrades. Going for league wins only.

Want to downgrade Giles for Campbell but if Mummy goes down I could be in massive strife heading into finals.

Anyone else in a similar boat? A risky call that could go either way.

[HBTD22]

Why not hold onto Giles and downgrade Mummy? He looked pretty sore in the game last week, I wouldn't trust him with his back injuries. Maybe wait a week and see how Campbell goes this week, if he scores well then it could be a legitimate option to consider. Although, it leaves you one true ruck premo short. Tough call.

[Chopps]

if you get rid of giles, i personally would keep a trade to upgrade mummy when its needed

[Mr Adams]

Would love to wait a week on Campbell but staring at a donut in the backline now with Clarke and Darley out.

Downgrading Redden might be a better move, but it's a fair bit of cash less that I would make. Very tough call.