Is Dempsey a keeper?

Started by Jormas, June 26, 2012, 06:24:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Keep him?

Yes
7 (50%)
No
7 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jormas

Either keep him, or trade him later for Enright?

would you consider him as a good B7? or prefer Enright?

what $$ will he peak at, i'm thinking 370K, then i'll try and sell him.

Current backs: GOD, Lids, Broughts, Waters, Birchall, Hargrave, Dempsey (Shaw, Darley)

Next week going Hargrave -> Carrots.


HELP WILL BE CHEERED

Ash A

if you have the cash, heath scotland would be the bloke to go to :) dempsey is a good scorer but if you have the money and trades, then scotty is the way to go

Spinking

I feel like he has had the potential to put on a bit score most games, without actually delivering.  He racks up those easy poss. around half back a bit like Lake, but also seems to go missing a bit.

I've got him at D7 at the moment, but I'm saving a trade specifically for him, as he doesn't appear to be very durable.  In his first couple of games back he looked like one heavy knock away from another lengthy sideline stint.

If you've got the cash and trades I think there are better options.

Jroo

Depends on how many trades you have left. If you have a few up your sleeve i would trade him as imo he is not good enough to be a keeper but if you are low on trades he will have to do and you will hope he dosent get injured and he can pump out some big scores!

Thunderstruck

He has the potential to be the D7 keeper. Presently thats the scenario Im looking at and while he is knocking out 75-85's I'll accept it.


rider

if you have the trades and other lines are good, then trade him. Enright is ok, but Scotland would be better or Heppel if you can't afford him.

Aaron8

Quote from: rider on June 26, 2012, 06:49:22 PM
if you have the trades and other lines are good, then trade him. Enright is ok, but Scotland would be better or Heppel if you can't afford him.

maybe even suckling

jmoynihan9

as D7 id say he is a keeper, but as said above if you have enough trades scotland is a good option and also suckles

Justin Bieber

If I did him instead of Hargrave, I would be pretty estatic.



Locinator

I would keep him until finals. He should get you a regular 80

JBs-Hawks

Hes my D7 for the rest of the year

Plastic Boy

I have Dempsey, Drummond and Hargrave.

I'm looking at trading Drummond and Hargrave for Carrazzo and Sam Fisher as a late season punt

Colliwobblers

I have dempsey and hargrave, trading hargrave to carrazzo after round 13 and KEEPING Dempsey.

They want the ball in his hands out of defence he should only get better as the year goes on.