Last trade of the year.

[upthemaidens]

easy answer,, hargraves to waters...  hargraves isnt even making the team atm..  though if you dont have carrots or scotland  i would probably get one of them instead of waters, but whatever

[Proudy1032]

Hargrave averaging 77, maximum of 111. Waters averaging 97, maximum of 126. That nets me around 20 extra ppg you would think and higher ceilings.

Barlow averaging 97.5 (Minus his two sub scores), Swan averaging 126. Swan ceiling of 171, Barlow ceiling of 109. Therefore 28.5 extra ppg if I go swanny.

Obviously these are estimates based on averages. Barlow was on about 70 something at half time against Bombers so he is showing his potential (as we have already seen in 2010).

Hard decision...

[Proudy1032]

Oh and I can get any defender from Gravey and any midfielder from Barlow, so if you guys have any other suggestions other than Swan and Waters feel free.
Darley, Heppell, Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Hargrave, Lake (Shaw, Bugg)

Redden, Scotty T, Gablett, Jelwood, Boyd, Barlow (Sexton, Gibson)

[upthemaidens]

Oh and I can get any defender from Gravey and any midfielder from Barlow, so if you guys have any other suggestions other than Swan and Waters feel free.
Darley, Heppell, Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Hargrave, Lake (Shaw, Bugg)

Redden, Scotty T, Gablett, Jelwood, Boyd, Barlow (Sexton, Gibson)

personally i would take scotland over waters, but either is better than gravey... like i said hargraves isnt even making the team, so its a no-brainer in my book