Hayden Crozier Vs Sam Gibson

[R.Griffen]

Hayden Crozier on bubble but has been sub in both games named at Forward Pocket
Sam Gibson only played 1 named at Half Forward

[Hagebear]

Gibson!! Mature age, dominated VFL and scott loves him. Has a much higher ceiling then crozier and a better JS.

[Zombie2.5]

Gibson. Everything about him screams Pick Me! Pick Me! (at least, over Croz)
Better JS, Mature aged, ball magnet, and is actually a midfielder, whereas i think Crozier is more of a small forward, tend not to score too well.

Unless you're planning to get both(in that case Croz first obviously), Gibson all the way. a mid forward link might be a factor but i still reckon Gibson.

[Tominator]

Gibson hands down.

[henry]

Yeah, going devon smith to gibson this week if he's dropped otherwise next week. Crozier is an ideal player for the green vest, as shown in his first 2 games. He is a good chance to be sub each week, which also means he is on the fringe and may nit have good JS. Gibson for me, has a very good tank due to his experienve training/playing VFL so os less likely to be the sub, also shoild score pretty decently and average hopefully ~75. Gibson - you're in!

[Tominator]

Yeah, going devon smith to gibson this week if he's dropped otherwise next week. Crozier is an ideal player for the green vest, as shown in his first 2 games. He is a good chance to be sub each week, which also means he is on the fringe and may nit have good JS. Gibson for me, has a very good tank due to his experienve training/playing VFL so os less likely to be the sub, also shoild score pretty decently and average hopefully ~75. Gibson - you're in!

do that trade this week regardless of whether Smith is selected or not - Smith is going to leak cash if he plays and if you're gonna do the trade next week anyway then why wait? That extra $10-15K gained from doing it this week could come in very handy down the track, I'm doing that exact trade this week

[BillyPil]

Yeah, going devon smith to gibson this week if he's dropped otherwise next week. Crozier is an ideal player for the green vest, as shown in his first 2 games. He is a good chance to be sub each week, which also means he is on the fringe and may nit have good JS. Gibson for me, has a very good tank due to his experienve training/playing VFL so os less likely to be the sub, also shoild score pretty decently and average hopefully ~75. Gibson - you're in!

Don't think Crozier will get the green vest this week... I reckon he'll start on the field. Depending on what the game needs at the time though, he could well get the red. I expect Pitt or possibly Silvagni to get the green depending on if they choose to play him fwd or back.

[Andrew]

Crozier only scored 46 after playing 3 and a half quarters last week v Richmond. His average currently is like 25 so even if you waited a week, he'll only got up $10-20k. I'm not getting him this week but am keeping an eye on him.