Giles

[Jericho500]

Looking to trade Giles this week. However need help. Who could I trade for If I go Maric I'll get score this week none next. Griffen got bye so he is 0 mcevoy has bye next week Jacobs has already had bye but hasn't  really gone any good this year? Any advice would be helpful.

[Legen...DARY]

IMO Goldstein would be a good pick-up. should get back to his 2011 numbers with H-mac out and is underpriced. Also had his bye.

[Legen...DARY]

Otherwise, Cox or NicNat  8)

[Dave085]

What about just waiting for round 13 to finish. All youll be doing is putting the donut off for a week.

Maric is the best pick up this year for the rucks and is only in 11.25% of teams (I expected this to be much higher when i just looked it up!).

Maric's break even is 115, Giles' is 83, i dont think either way youll miss out much as far as cash is concerned so keep Giles and if you really want to trade get Maric in after his bye. Thats my opinion though...

[Jericho500]

Would it be better to go Maric this week as if Giles is back Maric will score more this week than Giles next and I don't have to risk that Giles isn't going to play or not? Or go godly and hope hmac can stay out awhile

[Dave085]

Sorry mate, i wasnt very clear at all...

What i was meant to get at was do you really need to trade?? Are you trading simply because Giles is missing a week, or because you actually wanted to trade him??

At this stage im keeping him till much deeper into the season and focussing on other areas. The injuries this year have hindered so many plans this year and most peoples trade count reflect this.

Earlier in the season i planned to upgrade him, but this went to shower when Mumford got injured and then Sandilands went down. I have now changed my ruck plan and am keeping him.

So, would you rather hold him for now and upgrade other areas, or did you plan to do this trade???