Sam Gibson poll

[Windigo]

I'd really like to see a game before committing on Gibson.

But he is a gun at VFL level...

[PowerBug]

For an 85k player i would wait. If he gets injured your stuck with him & most likely the sub this week.

Better to have an 85k player injured at M8 than a 150k player injured at M8. ;) And saying if he gets injured means nothing, because injuries can happen to anyone, at any time. :(

[owenbond007]

Thinking of trading Horsley straight to Gibson even though he hasnt played a  game.

Should i wait for Gibson to get on the bubble and just take Horsleys price drop or trade now and avoid price drop?

should of traded horse last week

Most unhelpful post ever mate. ::) Why don't you just help the guy out instead of saying what he should've done. ::) Maybe he made 3 upgrades last week, or traded out three guys with LTI's, so you can't make those assumptions. ::)


I would make the trade, pocket the cash. Gibson looks set to play most weeks form here on. :D

Seriously he should of though - dollar was dropping wasnt playing. JS issues starting to pop up.

Id look for a alternate to gibson, maybe trade horse for shaw and swing lids/god into mids for a week. Its hard to really gie the ideal advise when ya dont know the rest of the team.

[stew42]

I'm waiting two weeks and hoping that JMac will be maxed out. Will then make a few much needed upgrades :)