Hope for Jarrad Redden??

[Ricochet]

From Primus Press Interview:
Primus: "Alipate Carlile will not play this week having failed to meet certain conditioning standards. He'll play for South

Carlile was named at full back.
Now i know that Redden is not a backman but at least its another out so there is hope.

But then he said this:
Primus: "Lobbe is ready fitness wise and his form is reasonable "

Port Bench at the moment is:
Stewart
Lobbe
Redden
Logan
Moore Hitcock
Jacobs

[Fireballz]

Touch and go! Will have to have a look this afternoon to know for sure but my league opponents have the same ruck combo as me (cox/giles/redden/orren) so I don't mind either way!
Might be time to move Giles on as a few others have said.

[PowerBug]

From Primus Press Interview:
Primus: "Alipate Carlile will not play this week having failed to meet certain conditioning standards. He'll play for South

NNNOOOOOO!!!!!

But then he said this:
Primus: "Lobbe is ready fitness wise and his form is reasonable "

Woo, Lobbe is good. :D

Might be time to move Giles on as a few others have said.

Giles has one of the most reliable rucks though. And he doesn't score like a muppet either.

[jaffa35]

Redden worries me as an emergency though..... could Tom Hickey be a better option or Josh Jenkins even?

[Justin Bieber]

Well if Redden play, what we get 30 extra points?? haha

[woofy]

His a chance of playing if dogs play Minson, Roughie and Cordy?

[PowerBug]

His a chance of playing if dogs play Minson, Roughie and Cordy?

Maybe. Personally i'd like to see Daniel Stewart playing but i don't think that'll be the case. :(

UNder the roof at Etihad so the weather is irrelevant.

[Windigo]

There is a glimmer....But then your stuck with the idea of trading out Giles>gun or play Redden & net his 40 points.....Then who knows how long Giles will be out for.

[Justin Bieber]

There is a glimmer....But then your stuck with the idea of trading out Giles>gun or play Redden & net his 40 points.....Then who knows how long Giles will be out for.

GWS website, 1 week.

[Ricochet]

he's playing boys