Giles > Goldstein

[Chelskiman]

Probably sick of this thread, but this will be the only other trade I make this weekend, if I decide to do it, so I do need all the comments/advice/votes I can get, as it's a big decision for me.

Goldstein has been in great form, but I fear that his good run has come against teams that don't really have the best ruckmen.  He has GC this week, and I'd expect another big score, but after that he has a pretty hard run as he plays teams who have ruckmen that are either as good as him or much better. 

Giles, on the other hand, is out this week but will most likely be back next week.  He has the ability to score big, but if there was ever a time to trade him out it would be this week. 

One last thing I should mention is that trading Giles would save a donut, but even if I hold him I will still win my league game this week as my opponent has no chace with the amount of players he has out this week.

So yeah, basically is it really worth going to Goldy this week, knowing he may have a tough run coming up?

[owenbond007]

Who are your other rucks????

[Chelskiman]

Cox, Big O, Pyke.

[Windigo]

Get Goldy. Cheap and will rack up.  ;)

[owenbond007]

Id get maric - orren/pyke should be a chance of playing next week maric will continue to kill it with a favourable draw

[KingJB]

I'm very close to pulling the trigger on this trade also had a think about Jacobs who is remarkable cheaper than Giles! I looked at Goldys last season and he was pretty good against most oppo including a 144 against the crows and a 120 against the saints.

[Chelskiman]

Poll seems pretty one sided thus far, but I'll give this a bump to get some more views before making my final decision.

[lollipop man]

Goldy will be a great pick up, however, i wouldn't be ousting Giles for him.

[Thunderstruck]

I would hold, Goldy's scores will drop once HMac back in side

[Affliction]

I would hold, Goldy's scores will drop once HMac back in side

+1

[ShaynoB]

Pay the exta and get Maric! Not sure I would have said that at the start of the year :D