Cotchin or Mitchell

Started by EZA100, June 10, 2012, 10:04:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cotchin or Mitchell

Trent Cotchin
12 (50%)
Sam Mitchell
12 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 0

EZA100

Trent Cotchin or Sam Mitchell

DKFC

cotchin on the rise! will go bananas v gws nxt rnd and tigs draw is pretty good from now onwards

bradway

Hasnt Cotchin injured his elbow?

EZA100

he played on and finished off good so i dunno if he is gonna be alright but might get rested next week because its against gws and then they have a buy so maybe they might give him a 2 week break before they vs adelaide

The Bomber

Personally would get Cotchin. Incredible consistency and if Hawks manage a few more wins then they MAY start resting players. Only 4 points ATM from top spot (1 win)...

Cotchin is only 22, so even if it is some sort of injury (didnt seem to bothered during the game from what I saw), he should recover quickly and well. Also less chance of being rested given he is young blood...

Mitchell has a higher ceiling this year, but Cotchin has been much more consistent...

Mitchell range: 55-141             Cotchin range: 73-126            (this year so far)
N.O Times below 100: Mitchell = 3 Cotchin = 1

quinny88

Quote from: The Bomber on June 10, 2012, 10:33:23 PM
Personally would get Cotchin. Incredible consistency and if Hawks manage a few more wins then they MAY start resting players. Only 4 points ATM from top spot (1 win)...

Cotchin is only 22, so even if it is some sort of injury (didnt seem to bothered during the game from what I saw), he should recover quickly and well. Also less chance of being rested given he is young blood...

Mitchell has a higher ceiling this year, but Cotchin has been much more consistent...

Mitchell range: 55-141             Cotchin range: 73-126            (this year so far)
N.O Times below 100: Mitchell = 3 Cotchin = 1

Cotchin scored 130 vs essendon

The Bomber

Quote from: quinny88 on June 11, 2012, 12:39:45 AM
Cotchin scored 130 vs essendon

My bad missed that score. Anyways, even more reason to get Cotchin  ;)