Which defender to finish?????

[B.S]

Hi guys,
Having a few troubles picking a defender that will be best for the rest of the season..

My current backline is;
Deledio, Scotland, Goddard, Waters, Birchall, Carrazzo (?)  <S.Shaw, Darley>

If you think there are any better options (for under $390 000) please let me know

[EZA100]

would go with heath shaw probably the best of the group.

[Yoshi]

Looking at the same issue.

Out of that bunch I'm looking at Suckling & hate to say it H. Shaw.

[dswallow24]

Suckers , Heather , Heppell .

[HBTD22]

I reckon Suckling. Hawks are flying so should drop some massive scores in the finals when you most need them!

[fertalong]

Hi guys,
Having a few troubles picking a defender that will be best for the rest of the season..

My current backline is;
Deledio, Scotland, Goddard, Waters, Birchall, Carrazzo (?)  <S.Shaw, Darley>

If you think there are any better options (for under $390 000) please let me know

That backline is almost identical to mine except I have Ellis instead of Darley.
I'm actually thinking Grimes (who isn't on your list), but I won't be make a trade until finals.

[B.S]

Hi guys,
Having a few troubles picking a defender that will be best for the rest of the season..

My current backline is;
Deledio, Scotland, Goddard, Waters, Birchall, Carrazzo (?)  <S.Shaw, Darley>

If you think there are any better options (for under $390 000) please let me know

That backline is almost identical to mine except I have Ellis instead of Darley.
I'm actually thinking Grimes (who isn't on your list), but I won't be make a trade until finals.

Yeah cant afford grimes unfortunately

[Spinking]

Of those mentioned I would probably say Shaw.  He can be inconsistent, but so can all the others you have listed.  His advantage is a much higher ceiling than the others.

[Grazz]

Shaw Suckling its out of those two for me with Heppell third.

[Justin Bieber]

Pearce. But he sucks  :-[

[Ajax22]

Suckling/Shaw the 2 I would look at. If I knew Suckling would play every game then would take him but there is a reasonable chance he's gonna get rested against one of those weaker opponents soon. You would think Shaw would be more likely to play the season out

[tbagrocks]

had Suckels all year but that 30 odd last week was a worry? balls not in the Hawkes back line atm, look else where!

[dswallow24]

Suckling barely touched it against Bulldogs but he was back to his best on the wing against Collingwood. It was just a one off since Birchall was doing well and Mitchell.

Get Suckers

[KoopKicka]

Sucling, Shaw, Heppel or  Hanley :)

[Dudge]

Shaw for shaw i 'd say