Ask Q (8/6/12)

[elephants]

Thoughts on chapman as Captain?

I'm going... Beams, Sidey, Stanton, Lids or Goddard... Want Beams but have school on Monday :-\

[Master Q]

HMac > Pyke
Horse > Swan
JMac > Zaha

Those were the trades I made this week, what do you think?

Pyke is extremely risky...

It saves a donut in rucks this week (Cox and Giles have the bye) plus it did free up cash for the other two trades.  I only really need Pyke for this week as Cox and Giles will be back next week.  It was really only a short term fix, but getting him in helped get two premiums in.

I don't think it's worth it.

Thoughts on chapman as Captain?

I'm going... Beams, Sidey, Stanton, Lids or Goddard... Want Beams but have school on Monday :-\

1. You have school on Monday? 2. How does that make a difference :P

[elephants]

HMac > Pyke
Horse > Swan
JMac > Zaha

Those were the trades I made this week, what do you think?

Pyke is extremely risky...

It saves a donut in rucks this week (Cox and Giles have the bye) plus it did free up cash for the other two trades.  I only really need Pyke for this week as Cox and Giles will be back next week.  It was really only a short term fix, but getting him in helped get two premiums in.

I don't think it's worth it.

Thoughts on chapman as Captain?

I'm going... Beams, Sidey, Stanton, Lids or Goddard... Want Beams but have school on Monday :-\

1. You have school on Monday? 2. How does that make a difference :P

1. Yep, in WA :)

2. I feel so unsafe with my skipper playing while I'm solving maths problems, I prefer to watch my skipper play :P

Will probably still go Beams either way though ;D

[Master Q]

3 Minutes Left!

[Tominator]

What would you do here?

I have 6 options. Team has 8 donuts as stands, $85.8K in bank. Here are my scenarios:

OPTION 1 ($19.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Mitchell
Smith ---> Robinson

OPTION 2 ($10K left)
Horsley ---> Williams
Coniglio ---> Robinson
Smith ---> Chapman

OPTION 3 ($11.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Ebert
Porplyzia ---> Robinson

OPTION 4 ($148.3K left)
Coniglio ---> Sexton
Smith ---> Robinson

• Don't trade Horsley

OPTION 5 ($41K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Stanton

OPTION 6 ($252K left)
Horsley ---> Williams
Coniglio ---> Stanton
Smith ---> Sexton

• Upgrade Porps to Chappy or Stevie J after Rd 12

Cheers so much mate!!

and yes, I know, this is straight from my poll here - http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,61668.0.html

[Chopps]

Q, Morris & Redden Vs The Mullet Maric who scores more ?

[nickstiges]

Which option out of these:

Horsely > M Williams + 272k

or

Horsely > M Williams and
D Smith > Stanton (Can't afford Swan)

[Master Q]

What would you do here?

I have 6 options. Team has 8 donuts as stands, $85.8K in bank. Here are my scenarios:

OPTION 1 ($19.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Mitchell
Smith ---> Robinson

OPTION 2 ($10K left)
Horsley ---> Williams
Coniglio ---> Robinson
Smith ---> Chapman

OPTION 3 ($11.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Ebert
Porplyzia ---> Robinson

OPTION 4 ($148.3K left)
Coniglio ---> Sexton
Smith ---> Robinson

• Don't trade Horsley

OPTION 5 ($41K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Stanton

OPTION 6 ($252K left)
Horsley ---> Williams
Coniglio ---> Stanton
Smith ---> Sexton

• Upgrade Porps to Chappy or Stevie J after Rd 12

Cheers so much mate!!

and yes, I know, this is straight from my poll here - http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,61668.0.html

Read it quickly but I think 1,4 or 5.

Q, Morris & Redden Vs The Mullet Maric who scores more ?

1st  :-\

Which option out of these:

Horsely > M Williams + 272k

or

Horsely > M Williams and
D Smith > Stanton (Can't afford Swan)

Depends on trades... 2 without knowing...

[Colliwobblers]

Hey Q - Ruck question for you.

Redden or Stephenson filling in R2 spot this week??

Stephenson for me.

I don't have any questions but i'll cheer you anyway.

+1 Me too but I'll ask a stupid question for the cheer :)

1. should I trade pendles = planning to NOT

2. should I trade scotland = planning to DO

very low on trades will get only one donut in 12 and one more in 13 if everyone plays and team fully upgraded by round 14.

limited LTI trades remaining...... is 2 donuts for scotland - one in 11 one in 12 worth a trade given he will be back with plenty of games still remaining and is clearly a top 4 defender?

How many donuts for you this week?

5 with scotland trade 6 without it

[Master Q]

Hey Q - Ruck question for you.

Redden or Stephenson filling in R2 spot this week??

Stephenson for me.

I don't have any questions but i'll cheer you anyway.

+1 Me too but I'll ask a stupid question for the cheer :)

1. should I trade pendles = planning to NOT

2. should I trade scotland = planning to DO

very low on trades will get only one donut in 12 and one more in 13 if everyone plays and team fully upgraded by round 14.

limited LTI trades remaining...... is 2 donuts for scotland - one in 11 one in 12 worth a trade given he will be back with plenty of games still remaining and is clearly a top 4 defender?

How many donuts for you this week?

5 with scotland trade 6 without it

Yeah go with your plan although not entirely sure TBH...

---

That's it for this week!

Good luck and don't be afraid to cheer!  ;)