rate my team!

Started by supporter, February 07, 2010, 11:30:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

supporter

this is my 2nd year only

Enright, Duffield, Hodge, Gilbee, Pears, Jamison, Maguire. reserves: Jackson Trengove, Joe Dare

DalSanto, Vince, Cooney, Prismall, Palmer, Trengove. reserves: Scully, Bastinac

Tippet, Kreuzer. reserves: Cordy, Lobbe

Riewoldt, Pavlich, Fevola, Franklin, Rioli, Koschitzke, Watts. reserves: Robbie Tarrant, Gumbleton

Thinking of Lewis Jetta for Bastinac or Gary Rohan for Watts. Share your ideas

lozza63

Mmmm very interesting backs - Jamison if fit should keep the 50s- 60s coming for as long as u need him reasonable cash cow for sure! Don't mind pears he should run off his player and score ok - who is dare though 7/10 backs

Mids - no Ablett, don't like prismal much all u bombers do it seems, palmer looks set to miss rd1 not had a full pre-season and better at DT IMO. 4/10

Rucks - seemingly solid to me 9/10 two young guns who should keep playing 22 and improvers to boot!

Don't like Kosi much very 1 good one 2/3 shockers, fev bit pricey, watts needs another pre-season maybe @ 196cm those ones take longer - meaning limited opportunity perhaps - best to go for shorter mid or medium sized guys 4/10.

Overall about 5.5 out of ten

supporter

#2
.

Justin Bieber

supporter it's a good to to build on. not bad for a second year effort. Also my second year.  ;D

backs are decent. jamison won't score you well but will play. pears only in if he plays off half back and not full back. rookies will change after the nab cup so don't worry bout that yet.
mids look pretty solid. palmer just might not play round 1.
rucks: nice combo but tippett might be up and down.
forwards: too many KKP (fev, buddy, kosi and watts). these guys will be very up and down. look at other options (buddy could be kept since he is very cheap).

like Iozza said look for small mid type forwards (sylvia, dangerfield, ziebell, etc)

supporter

thanks for the replys fellas, heres what my team looks like now

Enright, Duffield, Hodge, Gilbee, Pears, Jamison, Maguire. reserves: Jackson Trengove, Joe Dare

DalSanto, Vince, Cooney, Prismall, Kerr, Trengove. reserves: Scully, Bastinac

Tippet, Kreuzer. reserves: Cordy, Lobbe

Riewoldt, Pavlich, Sylvia, Franklin, Rioli, Dangerfield, Watts. reserves: Robbie Tarrant, Gumbleton

changes - Fev for Sylvia, Kozzie for Dangerfield and Palmer for Kerr (smokey?)

Bs Flyers

I like Dangerfield a lot better than Koznitscke as he is so up and down.  Fev is still an unknown when combined with Brown.

NAB will tell but don't think Scully will play firsts early on Martin might be safer, same with Tarrant Dennis-Lane or Tapscott.  Another issue is that there is only the one really solid mid in Del Santo, others are very good but will they get 100s consistently? (I hope Vince does because I picked him too).

Forwards and backs both good with some different choices that could go well but have to watch Maguire and Watts to see if other rookies are getting bigger points.