Magner v Shiel

[Slap]

*  Both are in a similar situation and I'm deciding who to chop in favour of Zorko. 
*  It will be one of these two for me, as I want to gain that MPP link with my fwds before byes.

*  SHIEL: has heated up after no pre-season, but will he continue to improve above the 70-80 mark?
*  MAGNER: could be a lock for a 60-80 each week depending on his role.  Has proven he can crack the ton on a couple of  occasions.  A bigger body than Shiel, but plays in a terrible team (DT wise and in real life).

[fertalong]

Magner if byes aren't a problem. Shiel if they are.

[Windigo]

Magner if byes aren't a problem. Shiel if they are.

+1. Shiel for the chop.  ;)

[disco1992]

Shiel chop magner in round 12 to avoid donuts is the best option

[Football Factory]

Magner seems to play week in week out, Shiel will get rested here and there. They both score similar i would keep Magner but depends a little on the byes i suppose

[Slap]

well this backfired.  :o