Judd, Prismall, Sylvia, Priddis, Edwards, Thompson or Goodes

Started by daniel lucanus, February 07, 2010, 10:58:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

daniel lucanus

at the moment my midfield is:
gibbs, selwood, goodes, palmer, trengove and martin with shuey and bastinac on the bench.
i am not too sure about goodes and i need 3 grand to buy fisher, so i am looking to replace him, but i am not sure who.
i was looking at someone 400-430 grand.
please help me out guys

Justin Bieber

i would go with judd if you can cover him for the first 3 rounds. an absolute gun and should out score all others. After him perhaps thompson. pretty consistent dt scores past couple of years. would also mention priddis but likely to cop a tag if kerr goes further. was able to fair decent with the tag last year.

BU1101

Judd for supercoach, but for dt thompson, goodes and prismall are the picks. Not convinced on sylvia and priddis is a hack waiting to be found out while edwards is simply too old to trust. Plus if you cover judd with a rookie for the first 3 round you could be losing 50 points a game for that spot - thats 150 points you would need to make up before judd becomes a possible good pick.

Trav0

i like the look of prismall! should be able to improve his scores from last season, and with atleast watson and winderlich getting tagged before him and possibly McVeigh and Stanton, he is the 5th mifielder!

FLOPITOUT1