Keep Bugg? Keep Morris? Get Shaw or Heppell?

Started by essendon2, May 15, 2012, 10:42:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Keep Morris or Bugg?

Keep Morris, Trade Bugg
Keep Bugg, Trade Morris
Get Shaw
Get Heppell
Don't do a 2nd trade and just do Ellis --> Zorko

essendon2

Bugg's BE is 69 ~ averaging 76.
Shaw is averaging 100 in his past two - got Geelong this week,  scored 124 and 97 against them last year.
Heppell is averaging 91 this season and has got Richmond this week ~ 108 and 102 against them last year.

Morris has great JS, sub potential this week? BE of 15.

Already gone:
Ellis --> Zorko (14 trades left)

disco1992

I doubt Morris would be sub he is there number 1 small defender and a mature age!
And shaw  is my favored choice but be warned roller coaster ride

Tyes


Jukes

Don't trade bugg! He's a lock for defender rookie of the year and at D7 presents a solid 75 average with 3 scores of 90 already, and will only get better. Wouldn't trade Morris either he's also a great bench option with good JS and an ok scoring output of about 60 per week including a 27 dragging it down.

tbagrocks

what about the certantcy of Bugg meeting the Genral any time soon? at least a vest?

shezz150


essendon2

Ellis --> Zorko/Spurr
&
Morris --> Birchall/Waters

or no to the 2nd trade

shezz150

Hang on... Zorko is mid/fwd, u cant trade Ellis for him?

essendon2

Quote from: shezz150 on May 15, 2012, 07:56:55 PM
Hang on... Zorko is mid/fwd, u cant trade Ellis for him?
Smedts my friend... Smedts ;)

tbagrocks

Quote from: essendon2 on May 15, 2012, 07:48:35 PM
Ellis --> Zorko/Spurr
&
Morris --> Birchall/Waters

or no to the 2nd trade
I wouldn't trade Mozza

Thunderstruck

Quote from: tbagrocks on May 15, 2012, 08:02:24 PM
Quote from: essendon2 on May 15, 2012, 07:48:35 PM
Ellis --> Zorko/Spurr
&
Morris --> Birchall/Waters

or no to the 2nd trade
I wouldn't trade Mozza

Have to agree here with tbagrocks as mozza is more solid

Colliwobblers

not sure what to suggest not knowing what your current backline is ?