SC team, can I get some opinions?

[benny]

Can I have some opinions on my first draft..... be critical!!

BAC
Sam Fisher, Heath Shaw, Luke Hodge
Lindsay Gilbee, Corey Enright, Rick Ladson, Brad Sheppard
EMG: Jackson Trengove, Phil Davis

CTR
GAJ, Brad Sewell, Bryce Gibbs
Scott Pendlebury, Tom Scully, Dustin Martin
EMG: Luke Trapscott, Sam Bleese or James Strauss

RUC
Nick Naitanui, Matt Kreuzer
EMG: Robbie Wornock, Matt Lobbe

FWD
Ryan O’keefe, Jonathan Brown, Lance Franklin
Cyril Rioli, Robbie Grey, Jack Trengove, Ryan Bastinac
EMG: Robbie Tarrent, Scott Gumbleton

[DWEBBY5]

good looking side
def is set looks very good hopefully there all ready for round 1

mid good but scully and martin maybe IF YOU have money try to upgrade

rucks
Naitani ??? i dunno really risky but should play in 2010
warnock not worth having him at that price on the bench  maybe have jackson trengrove which will give you money

fwd looks good
get tapscott who looks to play in round 1 instead of tarrent

[benny]

Thanks,
does anyone think cunnington will get up after his "hotspot" he would be worth it if he is fit yeah??

[DWEBBY5]

he would but i wouldnt get him with his injury

[Heater]

IMO you have spent too much $ in the backline.  You have certainly gone for some high end players and plenty of rookies but not too many mid priced players.  The side is good if they (the rookies) all play 1st round...

[HillHero13]

Can I have some opinions on my first draft..... be critical!!

BAC
Sam Fisher, Heath Shaw, Luke Hodge
Lindsay Gilbee, Corey Enright, Rick Ladson, Brad Sheppard
EMG: Jackson Trengove, Phil Davis

CTR
GAJ, Brad Sewell, Bryce Gibbs
Scott Pendlebury, Tom Scully, Dustin Martin
EMG: Luke Trapscott, Sam Bleese or James Strauss

RUC
Nick Naitanui, Matt Kreuzer
EMG: Robbie Wornock, Matt Lobbe

FWD
Ryan O’keefe, Jonathan Brown, Lance Franklin
Cyril Rioli, Robbie Grey, Jack Trengove, Ryan Bastinac
EMG: Robbie Tarrent, Scott Gumbleton

I agree with Heater i think you have spent to much in the backline and if you do decide to downgrade downgrade to someone like Joel Macdonald maybe and upgrade Cyril Rioli or maybe get Hille for Naitanui and i would not get Gray in a struggling PA side....

Bastinac has all good news coming from north he will get games just watch nab cup to see how scott plays him.....


Robbie Tarrent for Luke Tapscott.......

Scully for marabito - scully still has his knee problem so has an interupted pre-season and melbourne said he won't be rushed into anything....


Cheers
HillHero13

[benny]

Thanks heaps...

[benny]

Few changes, how does it look now????

BAC
Sam Fisher, Heath Shaw, Luke Hodge
Corey Enright, Matt Broardbent, Rick Ladson, Brad Sheppard
EMG: Jackson Trengove, Phil Davis

CTR
GAJ, Brad Sewell, Bryce Gibbs
Scott Pendlebury, Tom Scully, Dustin Martin
EMG: Anthony Morabito, Ryan Bastinac

RUC
Kurt Tippett, Matt Kreuzer
EMG: Robbie Wornock, Matt Lobbe

FWD
Ryan O’keefe, Jonathan Brown, Lance Franklin
Cyril Rioli, Robbie Grey, Jack Trengove, Luke Tapscott
EMG: Robbie Tarrent, Scott Gumbleton

[bomberJohn]

Trengrove is a midfielder now so you cant have him in your fwd.