Please review and make suggestions, I will return the favour

Started by bomberJohn, January 22, 2010, 03:19:47 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

bomberJohn

     
Gday fellow footy fanatics. Need some suggestions on the team as i am hoping to beat my mates this year as i spudded last year:

defence
Chris Newman  $530,100         
Josh Drummond  $514,800       
Jed Adcock  $468,500         
Lindsay Gilbee  $458,100     
Marcus Drum  $304,700       
Rick Ladson  $251,800 6       
Brad Sheppard   $149,200     
EMERGENCIES
Jackson Trengove  $94,200
Phil Davis $94,200

CENTRES
Gary Ablett jnr  $751,700         
Joel Selwood   $594,800       
Aaron Davey  $513,100
Adam Cooney $489,000     
James McDonald  $397,600       
Dustin Martin  $169,200     
EMERGENICES
Sam Blease  $94,200
Koby Stevens $94,200 

RUCKS
Kurt Tippett, $430,200
Matthew Kreuzer, $425,300
Robert Warnock, $134,100
Jack Fitzpatrick, $94,200

Forwards
Ryan O'Keefe  $582,100
Steve Johnson  $478,500
Jack Ziebell  $324,000         
Trent Hentschel  $349,800
Kane Lucas $124,200
Lachie Henderson  $304,300 
Lance Franklin $471,400
Emergencies
Scott Gumbleton 94,200
Jack Trengove  $174,200     
Please give me some feedback as this is my second year doing this and really would like some help, so if you have any suggestions about who to trade and who to replace would be much appreciated. I heard Johnson, Davey and Drum were a risk so far.
I have 44,100 left over which isn’t a lot to upgrade with.

Justin Bieber

hello bomberjohn. its my second year playing properly as well.

defence - pretty good. adcock a little injury prone but a great player none the less. drum will be fighting with hunt for a spot in the team.

mids - davey could be put up forward if you want but is pretty inconsistent. Melbourne are getting green back so i think his mid time will be cut. mcdonald getting on a bit and is a tagger. could replace him with a palmer or mcveigh who are proven performers.

rucks - good combo.

forwards - put trengrove on field for lucas. stevie j is said to still be having problems with his hip so i would stay away from him for now. hentschel and henderson will be used as KKP but think hentschel should be traded out for dangerfield if he is fit for round 1.

HillHero13


bomberJohn

I traded:
drum for Tadgh Kenneley in defence
davey for Scott Thompson in midfield
and Stevie J for Pavlich.
I am unsure of wether trading out hentchel as he has had shocker with his knee and hammy. And I don't know much about Thompson from the pies.
Any other suggestions to make my fowards stronger?

bomberJohn

     
Gday fellow footy fanatics. Need some suggestions on the team as i am hoping to beat my mates this year as i spudded last year:

defence
Chris Newman  $530,100         
Josh Drummond  $514,800       
Jed Adcock  $468,500         
Lindsay Gilbee  $458,100     
 Tadhg kenneley $241,400 
Rick Ladson  $251,800 6       
Brad Sheppard   $149,200     
 EMERGENCIES
Jackson Trengove  $94,200
Phil Davis $94,200

CENTRES
Gary Ablett jnr  $751,700         
Joel Selwood   $594,800       
Scott Thompson  $501,200
Adam Cooney $489,000     
James McDonald  $397,600       
Dustin Martin  $169,200     
EMERGENICES
Sam Blease  $94,200
Koby Stevens $94,200 

RUCKS
Kurt Tippett, $430,200
Matthew Kreuzer, $425,300
Robert Warnock, $134,100
Jack Fitzpatrick, $94,200

Forwards
Ryan O'Keefe  $582,100
Matthew pavlich  $534,200
Jack Ziebell  $324,000         
Trent Hentschel  $349,800
Kane Lucas $124,200
Lachie Henderson  $304,300 
Lance Franklin $471,400
Emergencies
Scott Gumbleton 94,200
Jack Trengove  $174,200     

Any other suggestions to strengthen my foward line? I have just over 200K left and was thinking of trading someone to get Chappy? Do u think he is worth the price tag?

DWEBBY5

get rid of warnock for lobbe as that will save you 40+k then upgrade someone if foward line i no its not much

bomberJohn

That's ok, then which foward should I aim for and trade out

DWEBBY5

i think lids will be better then ROK so get lids instead of him and then upgrade henstschel or zieball then you will have a better forward line

who do you want more lucas or trengrove because if you get rid of 1 of them for bastinac and put bastinac on bench then more money

just trying to help u dont need to take my advice just thiking it would help

bomberJohn


Justin Bieber

lids is deledio but deledio is named as a centre only. thompson plays for the crows.

Probably upgrade hentschel as he is a KKP.