i think i've done pretty well on this one...

Started by splinta, January 14, 2010, 11:20:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

splinta

BACKS

Brendon Goddard         
Andrew Carrazzo         
Jesse W. Smith 
Luke Hodge         
Andrew Walker       
Patrick Ryder         
Tadhg Kennelly 

MIDS

Gary Ablett jnr         
Scott Thompson         
Dane Swan         
Trent Cotchin       
Tom Scully       
Liam Picken   

RUCKS

Dean Cox       
Wade Skipper   

FWDS

Nick Riewoldt         
Ryan O'Keefe       
Cyril Rioli         
Brett Burton
Chris Mayne         
Jesse White         
Jack Trengove       

EMERGENCIES

BACKS

Josh Hunt       
Matt Maguire         

MIDS

Rick Ladson       
Anthony Morabito       

RUCKS

Mathew Lobbe       
Robert Warnock         

FWDS

Sean Rusling
Jack Watts         

i think i've done pretty well.what you think???be brutally honest...

daly

not bad, but get rid cox, he is missing the nab cup, carrazo is a clanger king, and walker is always getting injured.

Justin Bieber

Pretty good team.

Backs - Walker injury prone. when hille comes back ryder might play forward or back and not on ball. Smith just like walker.
Midfield is strong but watch cotchin in nab cup and i would drop picken as he is more of a tagger. other good players at his price.
Rucks - Skipper starting is going to be a bad choice. He is a good bench option but not for starting. Cox missing the nab cup so you could look at downgrading him to upgrade skipper.
Forwards is solid. Burton could raise in price as long as his age doesn't catch up to him.

Why is hunt and ladson on bench? i reckon they are too much to be put on the bench. could move ladson to backline to get a rookie in mids bench.

Hondo71

Too much money on your bench I think.  Pick some more $94K guys and watch your options on the field open up!

eg, if you can't find room for Josh Hunt in your starting 7 defenders then don't pick him at all.  Personally, I'd find room for him.

Hondo71

Also, Dane Swan's starting price is too high to put him in from the start.  I'd look for a cheaper premium and they are out there.

splinta

so many views but noone has anything to say!!! ill take that as a good thing...

jimmytigs

BACKS
Jesse W. Smith
Andrew Walker       
Tadhg Kennelly
MIDS
Trent Cotchin       
RUCKS
FWDS
Cyril Rioli         
Brett Burton
Jesse White         
EMERGENCIES
BACKS
Josh Hunt       
Matt Maguire         
MIDS
RUCKS
FWDS
Sean Rusling
Jack Watts   
All those backs are worth looking at but id have no more than 2 on the same team.Cotchin is well covered by ladson but perhaps you could do better(put ladson in start & downgrade cotchin)rucks good but forwards frankly im not even considering any of those 5-rioli & white dont score a lot,burton is my tip for earliest retiree once season starts,rusling injury prone & Watts mmmmm up to you but not for me.     

splinta


Brendon Goddard  C/B BAC         
Corey Enright  B BAC         
Luke Hodge  C/B BAC       
Joel Macdonald  B BAC       
Rick Ladson  C/B BAC         
Tadhg Kennelly  B BAC       
Josh Hunt  B BAC         

Gary Ablett jnr  C CTR         
Dane Swan  C CTR       
Adam Cooney  C CTR         
Liam Picken  C CTR         
Rhys Palmer  C CTR       
Tom Scully  C CTR

Dean Cox  R RUC
Jared Brennan  F/R         

Nick Riewoldt  F FWD         
Ryan O'Keefe  F/C FWD         
Cyril Rioli  F/C FWD     
Barry Hall  F FWD         
Chris Mayne  F FWD         
Chris Yarran  F FWD       
Jack Trengove  F FWD       

Matt Maguire  B BAC       
Jackson Trengove  R/B BAC       
Ryan Bastinac  F/C CTR         
Sam Blease  C CTR         
Matthew Lobbe  F/R RUC         
Ayce Cordy  R RUC       
Sean Rusling  F FWD       
Scott Gumbleton  F FWD

few tweaks here and there.im pretty pleased,just not sure about big,bad barry???