Heath Shaw Help!

Started by dreamkiller, April 20, 2012, 07:07:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What to do with Shaw

Trade: Carrazzo, Scotland, Suckling
2 (50%)
Keep/Wait: Play Ellis on field
2 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 0

dreamkiller

Should i trade him or keep on bench

if im trading i was thinking

carrazzo, scotland or suckling?

If not im playing ellis on field and waiting for him.

currently have 298500k and 23 trades.

thoughts?

Windigo

Tough choice.

He could be just 'rested' for the ANZAC game....

Carrazzo is who I'd go with.

Holz

With that money in the bank i assume you go for league wins, starting ellis inst that big a deal as some people are doing that anyway. Shaw could miss up to 3 matches but if you think you can cover him maybee hold. I would need to see your full backline to give a good opinion.

Lucastorm

Too many issues with Shaw, first he provides rollercoaster scores, now he is out for who knows how long - I'd say go with Carazzo simply based on his previous dt performances and the fine form the baggers are in atm.

I'm looking forward to when old carrots is back in my team :)

dreamkiller

Current Backs

God, Lids, Waters, Hargrave, Shaw, Clarke, Bugg (Ellis, Morris)

thoughts, was also leaning towards carrots

dreamkiller

winds do you have him and whats your decision with him?