S. Selwood or Boyd. Which is better?

Started by Duck, April 20, 2012, 03:09:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Best Round 11 Midfield Option

Boyd
S. Selwood

Duck

I'm looking for the best round 11 midfield option and I'm stuck between Boyd and Scott Selwood. I'm looking to get one of these and I'm stuck in a dilemma. I know Selwood has a breakeven of -3 and could make a lot of money but I'm not sure if it would be more worth it getting Boyd.
My mids at the moment are Ablett, Swan, Murphy and J. Selwood so I need someone with the round 11 bye.

colmullet

boyd is a keeper, selwood probably wont be come seasons end

kilbluff1985


TheMailman

Boyd by a long long way. Selwood is good, but not elite.

T Dog


esquire


Holz

Selwood is pulling out big socres win the eagles are crushing bad teams and he doesnt have to tag. Boyd is posting good scores when his team is getting killed, in the next 5 weeks he plays GWS, demons and GC I expect him to pump out some big scores.

Not even a contest