hav a crack at this dt see wat you think then maybe add some advice

[starz]

i just want to hear peoples thoughts about this team. it is definately going to change before the nab cup

goddard
fisher
hodge
mcphee
walker/ellis/suban don't know who to put in this position can i hear some advice please
ladson
kennelly

maquire
davis

gibbs
selwood
cooney
ward
palmer
martin

bastanic
shuey

cox
hille

lobbe
skipper

sylvia
pav
franklin
ziebel
dangerfield
trengrove
cunnington

gumbleton
tapscott

[Anzac]

Hey mate,

looks like quite a strong team there, very well balanced and the only concern i have is that you've got a lot of backline players from the same teams ie Goddard, Fisher, i guess they do play different roles though so it could work out. 

Im not sure who id go with out of those 3 guys, Ellis is the guy i would probably go with but then that would leave u with 3 hawks players, there are some other guys around that 200k mark who are alrite such as Buckley and Broadbent who u could slot in.

also remember Buddy is missing round 1 (not really a problem there cause u can just play 3 rookies)

Im also not too sure about Hille at this stage, apparntly he's recovered well but watch his pre-season form if he plays.  Another option mite be Seaby there

[Kangamagic]

Starz,

Out of the 3 I would go with Ellis his numbers are better. Walker is to risky he cant stay on the park and Suban maybe if you do go with him would free up abit of cash to spend elsewhere.

Magic

[starz]

yeh i like ellis and i think he is having an injury free pre seson but he seems to get injured to easily. are there any others around his price that could be good pick ups.

kangamagic i asume you are a kangaroos supporter wat are your thoughts on ziebell.

[starz]

also wat do you think of starting brad sheppard

[ronl]

Hey Starz
I think I'd go with Suban simply because he'll play 22 games if fit and supposedly is training the house down over there.  Ellis is physically unreliable and, as for Walker, too much "other stuff" going on with him.  I wouldn't feel confident having him in my team.