sidebottom vs harvey and sandi vs ryder vs nic nat

Started by HotTiges, April 20, 2012, 08:22:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

fyfe and mummy for who

sidebottom
2 (14.3%)
boomer
1 (7.1%)
sandi
2 (14.3%)
ryder
3 (21.4%)
nic nat
6 (42.9%)

Total Members Voted: 2

HotTiges

still cannot decide the 2 trades.. like Ryder at the mo as a pod on this board but sandi is pretty bullet proof except for his toe. nic nat another pod im looking at.. with the fyfe trade harvey is my fav but like sidebum in an improving pies side..

FonFatty

I dont want to do a trade that Iwill possibly regret.
If you have no link between fwd and mids, I would wait until next week to pull the pin on Fyfe.
Next week I will be doing C Smith --> Treloar and Fyfe --> J Selwood.
I have been tossing up between Harvey and Cloke, but they really do not impress me, YET.. Boomer of 2 years ago I would have snapped up pre-season, at the moment, yes he is getting a few touches, but they are all cheap uncontestd junk time posis.
Take the safe option and trade next week, that is unless you have no cover and are facing a donut.

HotTiges

normally hold on both but 2 doughies which is rough..

HotTiges

yeah Boomer, still avg 111 and super consistent and super durable..

Ringo

Can only select one in poll but my choices would be Boomer and Nic Nat

roo boys!


HotTiges

looked at nic nat as i have no eagles at the mo.. hmm

HotTiges

went sandles and pretty happy if he gets over a little niggle he picked up

ubeaut

Quote from: HotTiges on April 21, 2012, 12:06:51 AM
went sandles and pretty happy if he gets over a little niggle he picked up
Won't regret it mate. Sandi IS the best SC ruck now.