first draft - help

[vitch]

First draft - any comments appreciated

ryder, waite, walker, myers, waters, ladsen, kennelly (hill, maguire)

selwood, hodge, prismal, cotchen, masten, scully (melksham, cunningham)

ottens, tippett (leuenberger, hille)

reiwoldt bradshaw, hurley, watts, dangerfield, ziebell gumbleton (rohan, jurrah)  :-\

[scottydude182]

watch riewoldts pre-season might a good upgrade target after he drops in price...he hasnt started training yet

[jehan]

Paul Roos has said that there is very little chance of Rohan playing this year, incredible talent but he's got to bulk up first.  just out of curiosity how much cash have you got left over?

[Clint-84]

This team will score u 1500 - 1600 if ur lucky

[hibbo]

Would just start again. Every position IMO is too weak maybe apart from the midfield. A few pointers. You've spent too much cash on your bench. Hill, Hille, Leuenburger and Jurrah shouldbe on your field or not in your team at all. You should consider starting 1 or 2 more rookies - maybe one in your backline at the expense of Waters, Kennelly or Myers and one more in your forward line at the expense of Watts.

The money freed up from these changes should allow you to grab a few more premiums.

[vitch]

appreciate your comments guys, thanks for the heads up on Riewoldt Scotty, I had'nt really looked closely at who's training yet, he is just my first locked in player, some good pointers Hibbo I take on board your comments re over spend on bench players - will address, Jehan this team only leaves me with $29,600. Would greatly appreciate further comment after I amend - cheers :-[

[vitch]

ok - take 2

ryder gilbee hodge birchall myers maguire kennelly (talia t.slattery)

swan selwood prismall cotchin hill scully (melksham cunningham)

ottens tippett (west cordy)

j. brown bradshaw franklin hurley dangerfield jurrah ziebell (j.grant rusling)


bit more balanced I hope, I'd still like to have Riewoldt in my forward line but i'm hearing you Scotty. What do you reckon Hibbo ?

[hibbo]

A good improvement, but IMO you need a better ruck combo. Need either Cox or Sandilands in there. To get the cash for this I would drop Jurrah to a rookie and then upgrade Tippet or Ottens. Some players in your team I'm not sure on, but there's still heaps of time to get the right core of players.

[vitch]

Thanks Hibbo, i'm pretty happy with my rucks as a starting pair, my natural inclination is to go with Cox but I may just watch him as i'm a bit concerned how he'll come back. Who otherwise in my lineup do you query because i'm a long way from being happy yet especially my forward line.

[vitch]

just put take 3 thru fanplanner - comes up as 1748 although is rating Prismall as a rookie @ 46.4  ??? - structure 8/10/7/5.

hodge shaw gilbee myers kennelly buckley maguire (talia t. slattery)

j.selwood prismall gibbs higgins hill scully (melksham cunnington)

ryder ottens (cordy west)

j.brown r.murphy bradshaw ziebell hurley m.morton dangerfiled (gumbleton rusling)    comments welcome  :-\ :-\ :-\